Tax on Social Security Benefits: Criticism and New Proposals

Retirement planning can be a complex process, and many are surprised to learn that Social Security payments are subject to federal taxes. This taxation has drawn significant criticism and sparked various proposals aimed at reform.

Every month, approximately 70 million people receive Social Security payments. Of these beneficiaries, about 40% pay taxes on their benefits. The IRS has a specific formula for determining the taxable portion of Social Security benefits. If your income exceeds $25,000 (filing individually) or $32,000 (filing jointly), you must pay federal taxes on part of your benefits. Generally, if Social Security is your only source of income, it likely won’t be taxable. However, it’s important to note that 12 states also impose taxes on Social Security benefits.

The “You Earned It, You Keep It Act,” introduced by Rep. Angie Craig (D-MN) in January 2024, is one of the latest legislative efforts to address this issue. This bill aims to eliminate federal taxes on Social Security benefits. If passed, it would increase income for some retirees by removing the tax burden on their benefits. To offset the loss in revenue, the bill proposes to apply Social Security tax to a larger portion of the income earned by higher-income working individuals.

Proponents argue that this bill could significantly extend the solvency of the Social Security program. An analysis suggests it could keep Social Security solvent through 2054, far beyond the current projected collapse in 2031. However, the passage of such bills remains uncertain. Legislative efforts to reform Social Security taxation have faced numerous challenges, and bipartisan support is crucial for implementing any significant changes.

Critics of the current system argue that taxing Social Security benefits places an undue burden on retirees who rely on these payments as a primary source of income. They contend that the system should be reformed to ensure that retirees receive the full benefit of their earned Social Security payments without facing additional taxes.

On the other hand, some experts caution that removing taxes on Social Security benefits without an alternative revenue source could exacerbate the program’s financial challenges. They emphasize the need for balanced reforms that protect retirees while ensuring the program’s long-term sustainability.

As the debate continues, retirees and those nearing retirement need to stay informed about potential changes to Social Security taxation. Understanding the current system and proposed reforms can help individuals make more informed decisions about their retirement planning and financial future.