Connect with us

Historically Speaking

America 250: The Battle of Long Island

Published

on

Back in July, I wrote a column about the Declaration of Independence in which I praised the document while also arguing that, in many ways, it was worthless. Its ideas were revolutionary, but words alone did little to secure American independence. To accomplish that, the colonists would have to defeat the greatest military power in the world, a task that seemed almost impossible.

The war had actually begun more than a year earlier, in April 1775, with the shots fired at Lexington and Concord. However, a major turning point occurred March 1776. I wrote a column then about General Henry Knox’s remarkable effort to transport artillery from Fort Ticonderoga to Boston, a journey of more than 300 miles. Once those guns were in place, the British abandoned Boston, but General George Washington knew they would return.

Washington correctly predicted that the British would target New York. Their objective was not simply to capture the city but to control the mouth of the Hudson River. Britain’s early strategy was to seize the river and cut New England off from the rest of the colonies. British leaders wrongfully believed New England was the center of the rebellion and that isolating it would quickly end the war.

Washington moved his army of 19,000 soldiers to present-day Lower Manhattan and began strengthening the city’s defenses. He reinforced harbor batteries and built fortifications in northern Manhattan and on Brooklyn Heights. At that point in the war, Washington had yet to learn that his inexperienced troops could not stand toe-to-toe with the professional British army. He believed he could defend the city.

He was wrong.

In July 1776, 400 British ships carrying 32,000 troops under General William Howe arrived at Staten Island. Preparing for the attack, Washington placed General Israel Putnam in command of the defenses on Brooklyn Heights. Although guards were stationed along the major roads, Washington failed to secure Jamaica Pass, a little-used route east of the American lines. That oversight became one of the most significant mistakes of the war.

Howe quickly took advantage of the weakness. On the night of Aug. 26, he led 10,000 British soldiers through the lightly defended pass, allowing them to attack the Americans from behind.

The Battle of Long Island began on the morning of Aug. 27, 1776. British forces launched coordinated attacks against American positions while Hessian soldiers and British regulars overwhelmed troops south of Brooklyn under the command of General John Sullivan. Washington quickly crossed the East River from Manhattan, but there was little he could do except watch the battle unfold.

Sullivan’s men fought bravely but suffered heavy losses from Hessian artillery and bayonet attacks. Realizing his troops were in danger of being surrounded, Sullivan ordered a retreat before eventually being captured.

Although the battle ended in a major British victory, historian David McCullough argued in his Pulitzer Prize-winning book “1776” that Washington’s leadership during the evacuation prevented an even greater disaster. Washington was also learning an important lesson: he could not fight the British army in a conventional battle; he would have to adapt his strategy if the revolution was to survive.

My favorite part of the story happened that night, and, to me, it explains how the American army ultimately won the war.

After Howe halted his assault and began surrounding the American position, Washington ordered a silent nighttime withdrawal. Campfires continued to burn, giving the impression that the Continental Army was preparing to defend its position the next day. Instead, Washington gathered every available vessel, from military transports to small fishing boats. Throughout the night and into the following morning, approximately 9,000 Continental soldiers were quietly ferried across the East River to Manhattan.

The problem was that as dawn approached, nearly one-third of the army had yet to cross. Washington knew that once the British discovered the evacuation, they would attack and capture the soldiers left behind, troops he could not afford to lose.

Then something remarkable happened.

As the sun began to rise, a thick fog settled over the battlefield, concealing the remaining American troops and allowing them to complete their escape. According to eyewitness accounts, Washington was the last man to leave Brooklyn. Shortly after he reached Manhattan, the fog lifted. The army had escaped to fight another day.

There is no logical reason why a small force of farmers and tradesmen should have been able to defeat the most powerful military in the world. Many have called it fate, luck, or fortune.

I believe it was divine providence.

For the past 250 years, Americans have often spoken of a special blessing on this nation. Whether one attributes it to God or something else, the events at Brooklyn in August 1776 remain one of the most remarkable moments in American history.

James Finck is a professor of American history at the University of Science and Arts of Oklahoma. He can be reached at james.finck@swoknews.com. Thanks to the Southwest Ledger and the Lawton Constitution for sharing his column.

Front Royal, VA
43°
Clear
7:00 am4:56 pm EST
Feels like: 43°F
Wind: 0mph NE
Humidity: 65%
Pressure: 30.37"Hg
UV index: 0
FriSatSun
72°F / 36°F
66°F / 46°F
59°F / 50°F
Legislative Update5 hours ago

Cline Highlights New Bankruptcy Law for Small Businesses, House Action on Veterans Benefits

Crime/Court5 hours ago

Warren County Man Sentenced to 110 Years in Child Sexual Abuse Material Case

Community Events6 hours ago

Community Breakfast at Riverton Church Serves More Than Just Pancakes on November 21

Community Events6 hours ago

Loving Souls Christian Church to Host Soup Outreach in Front Royal

National News7 hours ago

Virginia’s Highland County Christmas Tree Headed to White House for National Holiday Celebration

Local News8 hours ago

Three UVA Health Hospitals Earn Top Grades for Patient Safety, Two Maintain Eight-Year Streak

National News8 hours ago

Lawsuit Challenges SNAP Restrictions on Sugary Drinks, Food in 18 States

National News8 hours ago

FEMA Chief, US House Members Push for Emergency Management Changes

Local News9 hours ago

Shenandoah River State Park Could Gain 640 Acres Under Virginia Conservation Grants

Health10 hours ago

Sold as a Natural Supplement, Kratom Is an Opioid, UVA Poison Expert Warns

State News10 hours ago

Spanberger Unveils Virginia Housing Plan Aimed at Lowering Costs and Expanding Affordable Homes

Community Events11 hours ago

The Millers to Bring Southern Gospel Music to Front Royal November 29

Local Government11 hours ago

Front Royal Issues Mandatory Water Restrictions as Shenandoah River Flow Drops Further

State News12 hours ago

Virginia Parents Weigh Screen-Time Limits as Schools Expand Classroom Technology

State News12 hours ago

Rural Advocacy Groups Band Together to Oppose Data Centers, Related Energy Projects

Food14 hours ago

Can You Eat Sweet Potato Skins? Here’s Why You Might Want to Stop Peeling Them

Mature Living15 hours ago

Move Over, Pickleball! Padel Is the New Racket Sport Gaining Attention Across America

Health16 hours ago

Red Wine Was Once Promoted as Heart-Healthy. Now Americans Are Rethinking Alcohol

Obituaries1 day ago

Franklin Roosevelt “Frank” Donaldson (1937 – 2026)

Local Government1 day ago

Warren County School Board Approves Structural Investigation at E. Wilson Morrison, Hears Progress on Substitute Program

National News1 day ago

Jeffries Chosen to Lead US House Dems, Poised to be First Black Speaker

Local Government1 day ago

Supervisors Tackle Agenda Including Permitting & Text Amendment Requests, Aerial Video, WCSO and Other Financing

National News1 day ago

FBI’s Stolen Gun Database Helps Firearms Dealers Spot Potentially Stolen Weapons in Seconds

Local News1 day ago

VDOT to Lift Most Lane Closures for Thanksgiving Travel as Holiday Traffic Builds

State News1 day ago

Spanberger, Lawmakers Reveal Proposals to Preserve and Build Affordable Housing in Virginia