Connect with us

EDA in Focus

Federal Judge Elizabeth Dillon Takes McDonald New Trial Motion’s Arguments Under Consideration After Friday Hearing

Published

on

Arguments were heard in Harrisonburg Federal Court Friday morning on former Front Royal/Warren County Economic Development Authority Executive Director Jennifer McDonald’s motion requesting a new trial. Judge Elizabeth Dillon took the testimony from both sides under advisement after the hearing adjourned.

It was estimated that Judge Dillon could take a week or longer to reach her ruling on the defense’s retrial request. So, stay tuned, legal drama fans, to see how the October 30, 2026 chapter of the Front Royal/Warren County EDA financial scandal plays out.

The Federal Courthouse in Harrisonburg. Below, Jennifer McDonald after one of her initial arrests and booking at RSW Regional Jail. Royal Examiner File Photos.

The last we heard, McDonald was imprisoned in a Texas criminal facility with immediate medical access for existing or emerging health symptoms, some of which emerged during her 2023 trial. If we remember correctly, her sentence for diverting EDA funds to her personal benefit was about 14 to 17 years.

Judge Dillon presided over the often-delayed trial, from August to October 2023, due to health issues among the involved parties, particularly McDonald. She upheld 30 of 34 criminal convictions delivered by the jury. This Friday, October 30, 2026, Judge Dillon heard arguments for and against McDonald’s request for a new trial. As previously reported, that request is based on a lack of information in the 2023 trial about one prosecution witness. That witness was Ron Llewellyn.

Background

As noted in this reporter’s Examiner story on the forwarding of McDonald’s motion for a retrial several weeks ago, “The McDonald retrial request was filed by her legal counsel from the Assistant Federal Public Defender’s office on March 19, 2025, apparently to assure it was filed within a three-year timeline mandated by the federal court system.”

Of that finally forwarded request, we noted that, “It is 17 pages of legal background that centers on financial issues regarding prosecution witness Ron Llewellyn. Llewellyn was a Warren County EDA Board member during the timeframe in which McDonald’s alleged financial crimes were primarily occurring between 2014 and 2018. What was apparently not known by the prosecution, and consequently the defense and the jury, was that during that timeframe Llewellyn had his own financial issues leading to criminal investigations.

As stated in the retrial filing, “Specifically, the undisclosed evidence relates to the fact that at the time of his testimony at Ms. McDonald’s trial in 2023, Ronald Llewellyn, a former Front Royal-Warren County Economic Development Authority board member, was under investigation by the Virginia State Police for forgery and embezzling property during the period between December 21, 2011, and January 18, 2018. As outlined below, this evidence undermines confidence in the jury’s verdicts here and the interests of justice require that this Court grant Ms. McDonald a new trial.”

Ron Llewellyn, left, being interviewed by FRPD in 2017. It may be noted that the financial charges pending against Llewellyn appear to relate to civil case accusations brought by his wife’s siblings after their and Corinne Llewellyn’s mother’s death. Our understanding is that none of those civil cases against Llewellyn in Frederick County were upheld. However, he faces two related criminal charges in Warren County.

At the upcoming motions hearing, which Judge Dillon set a three-hour time limit on and that ran from 8 a.m. Friday morning to shortly after 11 a.m., we guessed at the legal arguments that were on the horizon: “The prosecution is likely to counter the defense arguments to the court by pointing out that the alleged Llewellyn financial actions leading to criminal investigations and pending local charges were unrelated and irrelevant to the McDonald charges. And most importantly, it would not have impacted the jury, as defense counsel asserts it would have.

“But defense counsel will likely focus on the unknown ‘what ifs, ‘ leading to its page 17, final ‘Conclusion’ on its retrial submission: ‘For these reasons, Ms. McDonald respectfully requests that the Court grant her a new trial.”

Front Royal, VA
63°
Clear
6:50 am5:03 pm EST
Feels like: 63°F
Wind: 3mph W
Humidity: 48%
Pressure: 30.01"Hg
UV index: 0
WedThuFri
70°F / 46°F
63°F / 39°F
52°F / 36°F
Local News32 minutes ago

Blue Ridge Wildlife Center Patient of the Week: Canada Goose

arrest logo
Arrest Logs38 minutes ago

POLICE: 7 Day FRPD Arrest Report 11/9/2026

Community Events40 minutes ago

This Week’s Showtimes at Royal Cinemas as of November 12th

Local Government4 hours ago

Town Council Arrives at Consensus on Joint Tourism Agreement with the County

Local News4 hours ago

From Steel to Sharp: Front Royal Craftsman Turns Handmade Knives Into Works of Art

Food5 hours ago

Jest a Moment: Great Unheralded Moments in Food History

State News8 hours ago

Virginia Elected a Woman Governor. The State Constitution Still Says ‘He’

State News8 hours ago

JLARC: Data Center Tax Break Accounts for 60% of Virginia’s Incentive Spending

Opinion8 hours ago

Commentary: The Blue Tsunami Has a Message for Virginia Democrats on Data Centers and Campaign Finance

National News8 hours ago

Trump Open to Immigration Deal, Calls Crackdown ‘Too Tough,’ Despite Miller Promotion

Interesting Things to Know13 hours ago

That Flashing Orange Hand Doesn’t Mean Run: What Pedestrian Signals Really Mean

Food13 hours ago

The Secret to Perfect Snickerdoodles?

Local News1 day ago

Nationwide Emergency Alert Test Set for November 17: What to Expect on Your TV and Radio

Obituaries1 day ago

Kathy McDonald Butler (1973 – 2026)

Health1 day ago

UVA Researchers Develop Powerful AI Tool to Help Unlock Causes of Disease and Speed New Treatments

Community Events1 day ago

Samuels Public Library Holiday Open House Brings Santa, Mini Alpaca, and New Youth Gift Market December 12

Local News1 day ago

Would You Drive With Your Eyes Closed? Virginia DMV Launches Powerful New Distracted Driving Campaign

Community Events1 day ago

Mead Mile Takes a Turn Towards Youth-Oriented Community Nonprofit ‘Reaching Out Now’ for 2026 Event Fundraising

State News1 day ago

Virginia Could Lose Representation, Funding Under Proposed Census Rule Change, AG Jones, Housing Orgs Say

State News1 day ago

Virginia Localities Rethink Use of License Plate Readers Amid Privacy Concerns, Report States

Opinion1 day ago

Commentary: After the Blue Tsunami, Democrats in Virginia, Nationwide Should Avoid Misinterpreting Their Mandate

Community Events1 day ago

Cars Changing Lives Car Show Breaks Attendance Record as Organization Nears 100th Vehicle Giveaway

National News1 day ago

GOP Congress Faces Funding Deadline, Farm Bill, Lengthy To-Do List in Year-End Session

Health2 days ago

The Childhood Illness That Looks Like Slapped Cheeks: What Parents Should Know About Fifth Disease

Interesting Things to Know2 days ago

Unmarked Police Car Pulling You Over? Here’s What Drivers Should Know