Food
The Surprising History Behind Two Thanksgiving Dishes We Think Have Always Been There
Every family seems to have at least one Thanksgiving dish that absolutely must appear on the table.
Maybe it’s the green bean casserole topped with crispy fried onions. Maybe it’s the sweet potatoes covered in toasted marshmallows. And chances are, someone in the family insists the recipe has been handed down for generations.
But here’s something that might surprise you.
Two of America’s most familiar Thanksgiving side dishes weren’t passed down from colonial kitchens or created by early American settlers.
They were developed to help sell food products.
One came from a soup company’s test kitchen in New Jersey. The other appeared in a recipe booklet promoting marshmallows.
Both eventually became such familiar holiday traditions that many Americans have no idea where they originated.
Green Bean Casserole: A Campbell’s Kitchen Experiment
In 1955, a woman named Dorcas Reilly was working in the Campbell Soup Company’s test kitchen in Camden, New Jersey.
Her job was to develop recipes that home cooks could prepare using Campbell’s products.
That year, the company received a request for a simple vegetable side dish made with ingredients most American households already had.
Two ingredients were central to the assignment: green beans and Campbell’s condensed cream of mushroom soup.
Reilly and her colleagues experimented with different combinations, adjusting ingredients and baking times until they developed a creamy vegetable casserole topped with crispy fried onions.
They called it “Green Bean Bake.”
It wasn’t originally intended to become a Thanksgiving tradition. Campbell’s developed it as an easy side dish that could be served any day of the week.
But the recipe had several advantages.
It used inexpensive, readily available ingredients. Preparation was simple, and even inexperienced cooks could make it successfully.
As Campbell’s promoted the dish and eventually printed the recipe on its soup cans during the 1960s, more families began preparing it.
The casserole gradually became associated with Thanksgiving.
Today, Campbell’s estimates that green bean casserole appears on more than half of American Thanksgiving tables.
Reilly herself never expected that kind of success.
In later interviews, she explained that Campbell’s test kitchen produced hundreds of recipes, and the green bean casserole didn’t seem particularly remarkable when it was developed.
She also resisted taking sole credit for its creation.
“I didn’t do it; we did it,” she said, emphasizing her coworkers’ contributions.
In 2002, Campbell’s and Reilly donated the original handwritten recipe card to the National Inventors Hall of Fame.
The organization preserved the yellowed card as an example of an American invention that became part of everyday life.
Reilly died in 2018 at age 92, but her creation still appears on millions of holiday tables.
And somewhere along the way, a recipe developed to promote canned soup became Grandma’s famous green bean casserole.
Sweet Potatoes and Marshmallows: Another Marketing Success
The second Thanksgiving tradition has an even sweeter history.
Americans were preparing sweet potatoes long before marshmallows became part of the recipe.
Early American cookbooks included sweet potato puddings, baked sweet potatoes, and other preparations using sugar, butter, and spices.
But the familiar casserole topped with toasted marshmallows has a much more recent origin.
In 1917, the company behind Angelus Marshmallows wanted to encourage Americans to use its product for more than candy and occasional treats.
Marshmallows were becoming easier to manufacture, and the company needed new ways to persuade households to buy them.
The company enlisted Janet McKenzie Hill, a prominent food writer associated with The Boston Cooking-School Magazine, to develop recipes featuring marshmallows.
The resulting promotional booklet included suggestions for incorporating the confection into everyday cooking.
Among the recipes was a combination that would eventually become a Thanksgiving favorite: mashed sweet potatoes baked beneath a layer of marshmallows.
According to research discussed by the Library of Congress, the 1917 booklet contains the earliest documented appearance of that particular combination.
The idea was straightforward.
Sweet potatoes were already popular, especially in Southern cooking. Adding marshmallows created a sweeter, more decorative dish and gave people another reason to buy the company’s product.
The concept caught on.
By 1919, another promotional booklet included a recipe suggesting marshmallows on candied yams.
Other cookbooks followed, and the sweet topping gradually became part of holiday cooking traditions.
Over time, families adapted the dish to their own tastes.
Some added brown sugar and cinnamon. Others included butter, vanilla, or pecans.
And, of course, not everyone embraced the marshmallows.
To this day, few Thanksgiving side dishes generate as much friendly disagreement as whether sweet potatoes should be topped with marshmallows, pecans, or nothing at all.
But the marshmallow version has remained a holiday favorite for more than a century.
How Advertising Became Family Tradition
These two dishes tell an interesting story about how American food traditions develop.
For much of the 20th century, food manufacturers operated test kitchens that developed recipes around their products.
The goal was practical: Show customers additional ways to use ingredients they could purchase at the grocery store.
Companies distributed recipes through advertisements, product packaging, newspaper features, cookbooks, and promotional pamphlets.
Some recipes quickly disappeared.
Others home cooks adopted, shared with neighbors, and passed from parents to children.
Eventually, the recipes became family traditions, even after people forgot their commercial origins.
That’s what happened with green bean casserole and marshmallow-topped sweet potatoes.
One was created in 1955. The other appeared in a promotional cookbook in 1917.
Neither originated at the first Thanksgiving. Yet both have become familiar parts of the modern American holiday meal.
A Family Recipe Is Still a Family Recipe
Knowing that a favorite dish began as a marketing idea doesn’t make it any less meaningful.
A grandmother who prepared green bean casserole every Thanksgiving for 50 years created her own tradition, regardless of where the original recipe came from.
The same is true of a sweet potato casserole that has appeared on the family table for generations.
Over time, recipes become connected to the people who prepare them and the memories made around the table.
That’s why families keep making dishes year after year, even when newer recipes or ingredients are available.
This Thanksgiving, when someone sets down the green bean casserole or brings out the sweet potatoes covered in marshmallows, there’s a little history worth sharing.
The dishes might not be as old as the holiday itself.
But the family memories built around them are very real.








