Connect with us

State News

Was That Chicken Cutlet Grown in a Lab? These States Want You to Know.

Published

on

Select U.S. restaurants have begun serving laboratory-grown chicken, spurring long wait times for reservations by diners curious to taste it.

In June, the U.S. Department of Agriculture gave final approval for a few California-based companies to begin selling lab-produced chicken across the country.

While it may be years before lab-grown meat is available at grocery stores, a handful of states are tightening rules on labeling the new food, which is produced by growing cells acquired from living animals into muscle tissue.

Consumers interested in sustainable foods that avoid the slaughter of animals are driving the growing industry. But, pushed by the cattle and poultry industries, more states are defining what can be sold to consumers as “meat” and are requiring prominent labels on products cultured in labs.

Under a USDA agreement, UPSIDE Foods and GOOD Meat, as well as the latter’s manufacturing partner JOINN Biologics, will sell their products with the label “cell-cultivated chicken,” while the department develops further labeling rules.

However, some states are imposing their own additional requirements.

Texas passed the most recent bill, signed into law by Republican Gov. Greg Abbott in May. Starting Sept. 1, cultivated products in Texas must include the term “cell-cultured,” “lab-grown” or similar wording on the packaging near the name of the product, in type at least the same size as the text around it.

The Texas Farm Bureau, an advocacy group of farmers and ranchers, had listed the bill as one of its legislative priorities this year.

Goodbye almond milk, hello nut beverage? Lawmakers advance milk labeling bill.

In 2018, Missouri became the first state to pass legislation requiring different labeling for traditional meat versus products not derived from livestock or poultry.

Such products marketed in Missouri as meat without the words “plant-based,” “veggie,” “lab-grown,” “lab-created,” or a similar phrase before or after the product’s name may be referred to a county prosecutor and the attorney general for potential violations, according to a memorandum from the state. The products also must state that they are “made from plants,” “grown in a lab” or a comparable disclosure.

Arkansas, Kentucky, Mississippi, Montana, North Dakota, South Carolina, South Dakota, and Wyoming enacted similar legislation the following year.

In 2020, Oklahoma enacted a law giving state officials the authority to enforce meat labeling practices.

This year, Iowa considered a bill to prohibit lab-grown proteins in public schools, but it didn’t pass. A Michigan labeling measure remains in committee.

Kentucky’s 2019 law deems a food misbranded if it is labeled as meat but contains cultured animal tissue.

The cattle industry in Kentucky is extremely important to the economy, said state Rep. Michael Meredith, a Republican who sponsored the measure. People are interested in knowing about the origin and makeup of their food now more than ever before, he said, and legislators wanted to ensure labels are clear.

“I think the public is very skeptical of the product,” Meredith said. “I have talked with people — and I come from a fairly rural area — and folks are just appalled, and it’s not even funny.”

He added, “I think it’s going to be really, really hard to push something like this in rural America as a market.”

However, the cell-cultured meat industry has made significant strides in recent years. As of 2022, the global number of cultivated meat companies rose to 156, with headquarters in 26 countries, according to the Good Food Institute’s State of the Industry report. The nonprofit, which advocates in favor of protein alternatives and prefers the term “cultivated” meat, found that all-time investments in the industry had reached $2.8 billion globally last year.

The institute argues that U.S. state legislatures are taking steps to undermine the market through “label censorship,” which it calls unconstitutional and unnecessary.

“It’s always been our position that state label censorship through legislative efforts was kind of a ‘solution in search of a problem,’” said Laura Braden, associate director of regulatory affairs and an attorney at the Good Food Institute. “Consumer choice rather than label censorship should determine winners and losers in the marketplace.”

Still, legislators in states such as Wyoming, where the law requires labels on lab-grown meat to include “containing cell-cultured product” or similar wording, say they want labels clearly understood by the public.

“It never hurts to have our Department of Agriculture doing this work alongside the USDA,” Wyoming Republican state Sen. Brian Boner said. “We’re just going to have a more robust system where folks will know exactly what they’re purchasing when it comes to meat products.”

But such measures have met resistance.

The Missouri law prompted a lawsuit arguing the state made “a brazen attempt to stifle the growing grocery category of plant-based meats,” according to a statement from the ACLU of Missouri, which is part of the lawsuit—including the Animal Legal Defense Fund, the Good Food Institute and Tofurky, a plant-based protein company, a coalition of organizations challenged the law for violating the First Amendment.

“I don’t think this was about consumer confusion,” said Amanda Howell, a managing attorney at Animal Legal Defense Fund. “I don’t think this is about ensuring clear and non-misleading labels. I think this was about taking First Amendment rights away from companies and making them call themselves things that you know would be unintelligible to consumers. And if a consumer can’t tell what a product is, they’re not going to buy it.”

Howell said states are acting now because they sense the growing market possibilities.

“These are very animal agriculture-heavy states; their GDP relies on those animal producers, and they feel beholden to their constituents to pass these laws designed to attack plant and cell-cultured meats.”

Mike Badger, executive director of the American Pastured Poultry Producers Association, said poultry producers have long been expecting the approval of cell-cultivated chicken.

‘Fake Meat’ Battle Spreads to More States

The association represents independent farms that market directly to consumers, unlike poultry giants like Tyson Foods, which has been investing in lab-grown meat companies for a few years. While the traditional poultry farm community isn’t overly concerned about the possibility of competition, Badger said, there are still ethical concerns for consumers choosing cell-cultivated chicken.

“I think the really big question here is this: What’s driving the demand to create this new lab-grown protein?” Badger asked. “Is it only the fact that people think it’s more ethical than having a living chicken that dies for your table? And if that’s the case, how are the ethics of all the other stuff coming into it?”

Backers of cultivated meat argue it is better for the environment. Traditional meat is one of the top contributors to the average U.S. household’s carbon footprint, according to the latest report from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. In 2019, a sizable portion of the Earth’s greenhouse gas emissions came from the global agriculture industry.

A 2021 article by university researchers in India published in the Journal of Animal Science and Technology suggests that lab-grown meat could fulfill the increasing demand for meat using fewer natural resources.

But Badger cited an April preprint by researchers at the University of California Davis that found lab-grown meat’s environmental impact could be higher than retail beef based on current production methods.

“It’s very early in the whole process,” Badger said, “and there’s a lot of questions to be sorted out.”

Stateline is a sister publication of the Virginia Mercury within States Newsroom, a nonprofit news network supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity. Stateline maintains editorial independence. Contact Editor Scott S. Greenberger for questions: info@stateline.org. Follow Stateline on Facebook and Twitter

by Madyson Fitzgerald, Virginia Mercury


Virginia Mercury is part of States Newsroom, a network of news bureaus supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity. Virginia Mercury maintains editorial independence. Contact Editor Sarah Vogelsong for questions: info@virginiamercury.com. Follow Virginia Mercury on Facebook and Twitter.

Front Royal, VA
54°
Clear
7:00 am4:56 pm EST
Feels like: 54°F
Wind: 1mph N
Humidity: 45%
Pressure: 30.37"Hg
UV index: 0
FriSatSun
72°F / 36°F
68°F / 46°F
57°F / 50°F
Legislative Update2 hours ago

Cline Highlights New Bankruptcy Law for Small Businesses, House Action on Veterans Benefits

Crime/Court2 hours ago

Warren County Man Sentenced to 110 Years in Child Sexual Abuse Material Case

Community Events3 hours ago

Community Breakfast at Riverton Church Serves More Than Just Pancakes on November 21

Community Events3 hours ago

Loving Souls Christian Church to Host Soup Outreach in Front Royal

National News4 hours ago

Virginia’s Highland County Christmas Tree Headed to White House for National Holiday Celebration

Local News5 hours ago

Three UVA Health Hospitals Earn Top Grades for Patient Safety, Two Maintain Eight-Year Streak

National News5 hours ago

Lawsuit Challenges SNAP Restrictions on Sugary Drinks, Food in 18 States

National News5 hours ago

FEMA Chief, US House Members Push for Emergency Management Changes

Local News6 hours ago

Shenandoah River State Park Could Gain 640 Acres Under Virginia Conservation Grants

Health7 hours ago

Sold as a Natural Supplement, Kratom Is an Opioid, UVA Poison Expert Warns

State News7 hours ago

Spanberger Unveils Virginia Housing Plan Aimed at Lowering Costs and Expanding Affordable Homes

Community Events8 hours ago

The Millers to Bring Southern Gospel Music to Front Royal November 29

Local Government8 hours ago

Front Royal Issues Mandatory Water Restrictions as Shenandoah River Flow Drops Further

State News9 hours ago

Virginia Parents Weigh Screen-Time Limits as Schools Expand Classroom Technology

State News9 hours ago

Rural Advocacy Groups Band Together to Oppose Data Centers, Related Energy Projects

Food11 hours ago

Can You Eat Sweet Potato Skins? Here’s Why You Might Want to Stop Peeling Them

Mature Living12 hours ago

Move Over, Pickleball! Padel Is the New Racket Sport Gaining Attention Across America

Health13 hours ago

Red Wine Was Once Promoted as Heart-Healthy. Now Americans Are Rethinking Alcohol

Obituaries24 hours ago

Franklin Roosevelt “Frank” Donaldson (1937 – 2026)

Local Government24 hours ago

Warren County School Board Approves Structural Investigation at E. Wilson Morrison, Hears Progress on Substitute Program

National News1 day ago

Jeffries Chosen to Lead US House Dems, Poised to be First Black Speaker

Local Government1 day ago

Supervisors Tackle Agenda Including Permitting & Text Amendment Requests, Aerial Video, WCSO and Other Financing

National News1 day ago

FBI’s Stolen Gun Database Helps Firearms Dealers Spot Potentially Stolen Weapons in Seconds

Local News1 day ago

VDOT to Lift Most Lane Closures for Thanksgiving Travel as Holiday Traffic Builds

State News1 day ago

Spanberger, Lawmakers Reveal Proposals to Preserve and Build Affordable Housing in Virginia