Health
Red Wine Was Once Promoted as Heart-Healthy. Now Americans Are Rethinking Alcohol
In November 1991, millions of Americans tuned in to 60 Minutes and heard something that sounded almost too good to be true.
The French enjoyed rich foods, consumed plenty of butter and cheese, and drank wine regularly. Yet they appeared to suffer fewer deaths from heart disease than Americans.
How could that be?
The television report explored what became known as the “French Paradox,” and one possible explanation captured the public’s imagination: red wine.
For Americans who enjoyed a glass with dinner, the message was appealing. Drinking wine might not merely be enjoyable. It might actually be good for your heart.
Wine sales responded almost immediately.
According to historical industry reporting, U.S. red wine sales increased approximately 39% in 1992 following the broadcast.
Thirty-five years later, however, Americans have a dramatically different understanding of alcohol and health.
A new Gallup survey finds that just 6% of Americans believe moderate drinking is good for their health, while 51% now believe it is harmful.
It’s a remarkable reversal from the days when a glass of red wine was routinely promoted as part of a healthy lifestyle.
The French Paradox That Changed American Drinking Habits
The November 17, 1991, 60 Minutes segment, reported by Morley Safer, examined why France appeared to have relatively low rates of heart disease despite a diet high in saturated fat.
Some researchers suggested that moderate wine consumption might help explain the difference.
The idea was especially attractive because red wine contains compounds called polyphenols, including resveratrol, that have been studied for possible cardiovascular effects.
The suggestion that drinking wine could help protect the heart soon became a popular health message.
Restaurants, wine producers, and consumers embraced the concept.
But there was a scientific problem.
Much of the early evidence came from observational studies that followed people’s drinking habits and compared their health outcomes.
Those studies could identify associations, but they could not establish that wine itself caused better health.
People who drink moderate amounts of wine may also have different diets, incomes, access to healthcare, exercise habits, and other characteristics that affect their health.
The French Paradox did not prove that red wine prevented heart disease.
Nevertheless, the idea became one of the most influential health messages associated with alcohol in modern American history.
Only 6% of Americans Now See a Health Benefit
Gallup’s latest Consumption Habits survey, conducted July 1–19, 2026, shows how dramatically attitudes have changed.
When Gallup first asked Americans about the health effects of moderate drinking in 2001, 22% said consuming one or two alcoholic beverages a day was good for health.
Another 27% said it was bad, while 46% believed it made no difference.
Today’s responses tell a different story.
Only 6% believe moderate drinking is beneficial, while 51% consider it harmful. Another 40% say it makes no difference.
The percentage viewing moderate drinking as harmful is slightly below last year’s record-high 53%, but 2025 and 2026 are the only two years in Gallup’s history when a majority has held that opinion.
The findings also suggest that Americans are paying attention to changing medical research.
Gallup reports that 86% of adults have heard at least something about recent studies examining alcohol’s long-term health effects, compared with 79% in 2024.
The findings suggest that growing awareness of alcohol’s risks is helping reshape public attitudes.
What Changed in the Medical Research?
For years, studies suggested that moderate alcohol consumption might offer some protection against heart disease.
But researchers have increasingly questioned whether those apparent benefits were caused by alcohol or by differences between the people being studied.
One concern involves how researchers classify nondrinkers.
In some earlier studies, the nondrinking group included people who had stopped drinking because of illness or other health problems. Comparing those individuals with healthier moderate drinkers could make alcohol appear more beneficial than it actually was.
Scientists have also examined alcohol’s effects on cancer, liver disease, blood pressure, and other health conditions.
The evidence linking alcohol consumption to several cancers is particularly strong.
The International Agency for Research on Cancer, part of the World Health Organization, has classified alcoholic beverages as Group 1 carcinogens for decades.
That category means there is sufficient evidence that the substance can cause cancer in humans.
Tobacco and asbestos are also in Group 1, although that does not mean all three present identical levels or types of risk.
Alcohol has been linked to at least seven cancers, including cancers of the mouth, throat, voice box, esophagus, liver, colon and rectum, and breast.
The risk generally increases with the amount consumed.
Public Health Officials Issue Stronger Warnings
In January 2023, the World Health Organization published a statement explaining that research had not established a level of alcohol consumption that carries no health risk.
The statement emphasized that cancer risk is associated with alcohol itself, whether it is consumed as beer, wine, or liquor.
Two years later, in January 2025, the U.S. Surgeon General issued an advisory highlighting the relationship between alcohol and cancer.
The advisory called for greater public awareness and recommended updating alcoholic beverage warning labels to include cancer risks.
That represented a major shift from the public conversation of the early 1990s.
Instead of promoting a possible heart benefit from drinking red wine, health authorities were emphasizing the risks associated with alcohol consumption.
The science does retain some complexity.
A 2025 review by the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine found that moderate drinking was associated with lower overall mortality than never drinking in the observational studies it examined. The same review found an increased risk of breast cancer among women who drank moderately.
Such findings underscore an important distinction: an association in population studies does not necessarily prove that alcohol itself provides a health benefit.
Public health recommendations must consider all the potential benefits and risks, not just one disease.
Americans Are Drinking Less
Changing attitudes are reflected in drinking habits.
Gallup found that 54% of American adults now say they consume alcohol.
That matches the record low established in 2025 and represents the smallest percentage recorded since Gallup began tracking the question in 1939.
As recently as 2023, 62% of adults reported drinking alcohol.
Gallup also found that just 13% of Americans say they sometimes drink too much, another record low.
Some people are replacing alcoholic beverages with nonalcoholic alternatives.
In 2026, Gallup asked about that practice for the first time and found that 17% of Americans had consumed nonalcoholic beer, wine, or spirits instead of an alcoholic drink during the previous year.
Among drinkers who use these alternatives, 38% said they were consuming more of them than before.
Beer Still Leads, but Wine Has Its Loyal Following
Despite the decline in overall drinking, Americans’ beverage preferences have not changed dramatically.
Among adults who drink alcohol, Gallup found:
- 36% prefer beer.
- 32% prefer liquor.
- 30% prefer wine.
Beer remains the most popular choice, although liquor has gained ground over the past decade.
Wine continues to appeal particularly to older Americans.
Among drinkers ages 55 and older, 37% favor wine, compared with 34% who prefer beer and 25% who prefer liquor.
Younger adults show different preferences, with liquor and beer leading among those ages 18 to 34.
Should Someone Start Drinking Red Wine for Their Heart?
Current public health advice does not recommend beginning to drink alcohol for its possible health benefits.
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention advises that drinking less is better for health than drinking more, and that even moderate consumption can carry risks.
For people who do not drink, there is no medical reason to start.
For those who choose to drink, understanding the risks and limiting consumption can help reduce potential harm.
And while red wine contains antioxidants, those compounds do not mean drinking alcohol improves overall health.
The possible benefits of individual wine compounds must be distinguished from the effects of consuming an alcoholic beverage.
Thirty-Five Years Later, a Different Message
The 1991 60 Minutes report helped change American wine culture almost overnight.
It offered an appealing message: Enjoying a glass of red wine might be doing something good for your heart.
The intervening decades have brought a much more complicated understanding of alcohol’s effects on the body.
Scientists continue studying its relationship to cardiovascular disease, but the evidence connecting alcohol with cancer and other health problems has become an increasingly important part of public health guidance.
Americans appear to be responding.
With only 6% now saying moderate drinking is good for health, the idea that wine should be consumed for its medical benefits has lost much of its appeal.
The glass of red wine that once symbolized a healthy lifestyle now comes with a more important question:
Is the enjoyment worth the health risks?








