Connect with us

State News

In Dominion-NextEra Merger Opening Arguments, Parties Clash Over Potential Risk, Protections

Published

on

The legal case of the historic proposed merger of Virginia’s largest utility provider, Dominion Energy, and Florida-based NextEra Energy began Tuesday at the State Corporation Commission, with attorneys representing over 30 intervenors presenting their opening arguments in Richmond.

The crux of the debate is whether the $67 billion merger should be approved, creating the largest regulated utility in the world. State regulators must decide whether “adequate service to the public at just and reasonable rates will not be impaired or jeopardized” by the deal.

Several clean energy advocates and other interested parties in the case insisted that Dominion and NextEra have not proved that the deal wouldn’t risk rate increases.

Opponents also said the companies need to back up their claims that the deal’s boost to the companies’ energy infrastructure buying power will benefit customers.

“Petitioners have failed to provide any real evidence or analysis to support these claims or any enforceable conditions to ensure that customers will in fact benefit,” Appalachian Voices attorney Nate Benforado said.

The utilities argue that the law is narrow in requiring the companies to “do no harm,” and that the scope of the merger case should focus on the efforts to maintain reliable service.

Some intervenors have pushed to include NextEra’s  alleged involvement in political campaigns in past years as part of the evidence in the case.

Clean energy groups have also asked for a more robust plan of how the companies would work to meet the state’s Clean Economy Act mandates, as power demand continues to grow under the buildout of data centers across the commonwealth.

“This case, in our view, is simply not the one to litigate that cost of service, nor is it the case to litigate who’s paying their fair share, and ensuring everybody pays their fair share, including the data centers,” Joseph Reid, representing Dominion, said.

Intervenors outline concerns, potential risks

The companies said if they’re allowed to combine, their ability to bulk-buy energy infrastructure will bring down the cost of the energy projects.

The Sierra Club and other intervenors said Tuesday those savings would not be quantifiable or guaranteed.

In pre-filed testimony, SCC staff wrote that NextEra’s “unregulated, competitive business” exposed Dominion to additional risks. NextEra Energy Resources (NEER) produces energy infrastructure and is valued on the market value of power – which can be a volatile calculation.

“Rates that carry another company’s risk are not just and reasonable,” said Greg Habeeb, an attorney representing Clean Virginia in the case.

Bill increases are one of the top concerns the intervenors identified.

Dominion Energy customers have already seen a steep increase in the average monthly bill over the past two decades.

In a report to the Energy Commission of Virginia, the SCC reported that the average monthly Dominion residential bill “was $90.59 as of July 1, 2007. The bill has increased by $90.20, or 99.57%, to $180.79 per month as of July 1, 2026.”

The joint petitioners have offered a monthly bill credit of $10 a month for up to four years. Gov. Abigail Spanberger and Chief Energy Officer Josephus Allmond have asked for that rate to be increased to $29 and to have a base rate freeze for six years.

The attorney representing the governor’s office also urged commissioners to implement enforcement in the deal, to ensure that all that is being promised in the case by the two companies actually is implemented if the merger is approved.

“The commission has broad authority, under Virginia law, to impose civil penalties, require specific performance, and when necessary, unwind a transaction,” Matthew McGuire, on behalf of Spanberger and Allmond, testified.

Reid stated that the bill credit is meant to be a bridge between the current cost of bills to when the potential benefits of the merger would kick in. Clean Virginia’s attorney testified that these conditions don’t get to the heart of the risk that has been outlined in staff testimony.

“Every condition offered treats the symptom, but leaves the cause. The source of the jeopardy is NextEra’s control, and NextEra’s other businesses that are untouched by any proposed condition,” Habeeb said.

Reid pointed to the list of recommendations and policy changes that were recommended by SCC staff and the Attorney General’s office that the agencies felt would put the merger deal in a better position to advance.

The utilities agreed to the majority of the protections, but offered alternate plans regarding separating finances and resources, otherwise known as ring-fencing, in specific “trigger events” as well as other policy shifts.

“We hope that there’s some sort of peace in the valley here because the petitioners made an effort to make those conditions even more protective and robust than staff proposed,” Reid testified.

Other participants in the case have brought their own list of recommendations and policies that they want the utilities to consider.

Cliona Mary Robb, representing the Virginia Energy Purchasing Governmental Association, testified that the group was frustrated that Dominion and NextEra did not address their list of recommendations in their rebuttal testimony.

The utilities also didn’t remark on the governor’s recommendations in their filed rebuttal testimony.

The hearings for the case are anticipated to run through the Thanksgiving holiday. A decision must be made by the three commissions on the merger by Jan. 11.

 

By Shannon Heckt, Virginia Mercury


Virginia Mercury is part of States Newsroom, a nonprofit news network supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity. Virginia Mercury maintains editorial independence. Contact Editor Samantha Willis with questions: info@virginiamercury.com.

Front Royal, VA
37°
Clear
6:59 am4:56 pm EST
Feels like: 37°F
Wind: 0mph E
Humidity: 78%
Pressure: 30.49"Hg
UV index: 0
ThuFriSat
72°F / 34°F
72°F / 36°F
68°F / 43°F
Obituaries4 hours ago

Franklin Roosevelt “Frank” Donaldson (1937 – 2026)

Local Government4 hours ago

Warren County School Board Approves Structural Investigation at E. Wilson Morrison, Hears Progress on Substitute Program

National News4 hours ago

Jeffries Chosen to Lead US House Dems, Poised to be First Black Speaker

Local Government5 hours ago

Supervisors Tackle Agenda Including Permitting & Text Amendment Requests, Aerial Video, WCSO and Other Financing

National News8 hours ago

FBI’s Stolen Gun Database Helps Firearms Dealers Spot Potentially Stolen Weapons in Seconds

Local News8 hours ago

VDOT to Lift Most Lane Closures for Thanksgiving Travel as Holiday Traffic Builds

State News8 hours ago

Spanberger, Lawmakers Reveal Proposals to Preserve and Build Affordable Housing in Virginia

Crime/Court8 hours ago

Warren County Grand Jury Returns 28 Indictments Against 15 Defendants

Local News10 hours ago

Virginia State Police to Step Up Enforcement Along I-95 November 19–20

Local News14 hours ago

Front Royal Rotary to Dedicate Centennial Mural Celebrating 100 Years of Community Service

Scott's Turn14 hours ago

Why Visitors Spend More Than You Think

State News14 hours ago

In Dominion-NextEra Merger Opening Arguments, Parties Clash Over Potential Risk, Protections

State News15 hours ago

Virginia Lawmaker, Advocates Push to Expand Local Authority Under Home Rule Proposal

Commentary & Analysis15 hours ago

Commentary: Can Democrats Now Compete for Votes in Republican Rural Virginia?

Opinion15 hours ago

Leadership and Responsibility: The Unbroken Human Circle

Interesting Things to Know16 hours ago

Rising Diesel Prices Are Driving Up the Cost of Groceries and Everyday Goods

Food17 hours ago

The Most Overlooked Part of Holiday Hosting? Having Drinks Ready When Guests Arrive

Chamber News1 day ago

Five Years of Geek Culture and Community: Main Street Geek Celebrates Anniversary in Front Royal

Jefferson Forum1 day ago

Most Virginians Say No to More School Taxes

Historically Speaking1 day ago

Historical Election? Examining Mainstream Media’s Spin on American History

State News1 day ago

After Lucas Pleads Not Guilty, Locke Warns Against Senate Inquiry

National News1 day ago

US Senate Dems Call for Pause on Router Installation That Caused Air Travel Ground Stop

Obituaries1 day ago

Elizabeth Ann Jenkins (1933 – 2026)

Local News1 day ago

New Road Trip Planner Combines Skyline Drive’s Scenic Views With Live Music

Community Events1 day ago

Warren Coalition Invites Families to Free Game Night November 20