Connect with us

State News

If Virginians Approve Reproductive Rights Amendment, A Hearing Is Set for Nov. 13 To Challenge It

Published

on

If Virginians approve a ballot referendum on Nov. 3 to permanently protect reproductive rights in the state’s constitution, the amendment will be challenged in court on Nov. 13.

The case seeks a preliminary injunction to block the certification of the amendment referendum results by alleging that the process was not properly filed and that ballot language was misleading.

Founding Freedoms Law Center launched the legal challenge in April, but it has been stalled since June, when advocacy group Virginians For Reproductive Freedom successfully petitioned to join as a co-defendant.

An argument of the case is whether Virginia’s retroactive repeal of old state code concerning constitutional amendment processes can hold.

The old code would have required House of Delegates Clerk Paul Nardo to have sent copies of the amendment text to all of Virginia’s circuit court clerks to post outside their courthouses.

The repeal, which kicked in this July after the amendments had already gone through other advancing steps, removed that part of the process.

A similar case brought forth by Liberty Counsel was dismissed over the summer in a different court, but the group is seeking an appeal. At the time of the dismissal, Senior Assistant Attorney General Erin McNeil emphasized that state lawmakers have authority to adjust the constitution and prescribe how they do it.

“How can the General Assembly have this authority to prescribe a process but not have the authority to change that process?” McNeil said in court.

The argument, however, also surfaced as part of a successful effort to strike down a redistricting referendum voters had approved this past spring. That case, like the Founding Freedoms case, was advanced in Tazewell by Judge Jack Hurley.

“Not only would this proposed abortion amendment be a disaster for policy reasons, but it would undermine trust in our democratic processes because of the flawed and deceptive means by which it will have passed. We cannot allow that to happen,” Founding Freedoms lawyer Josh Hetzler said in a statement.

Constitutional: The amendment that could permanently protect reproductive rights in Virginia

The organization is also representing a Prince William County pastor in a newly filed challenge to a ballot referendum to protect same-sex marriages in Virginia, on the same procedural grounds as the reproductive rights amendment challenge.

A 2015 U.S. Supreme Court case protects gay marriage nationwide, but Justice Clarence Thomas suggested revising it and contraception access after the court overturned federal abortion protections. It’s part of why state lawmakers sent the reproductive rights and marriage amendments to voters.

Plaintiff in that case, Rev. Ben Purves, also co-signed a joint letter with 400 pastors from around the state opposing both constitutional amendments.

Founding Freedoms Law Center doesn’t intend to challenge the third constitutional amendment, which advanced at the same time and in the same fashion as the two challenged ones.

Ballot Question Three asks voters if voting rights should automatically be restored for people with felony convictions who have completed their prison sentences.

“We’re not personally concerned about the restoration-of-rights amendment,” Hetzler said in a phone call over the summer. “We don’t have a position on that.”

 

By Charlotte Rene Woods, Virginia Mercury


Virginia Mercury is part of States Newsroom, a nonprofit news network supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity. Virginia Mercury maintains editorial independence. Contact Editor Samantha Willis with questions: info@virginiamercury.com.

Front Royal, VA
54°
Partly Cloudy
6:49 am5:04 pm EST
Feels like: 54°F
Wind: 6mph WSW
Humidity: 55%
Pressure: 29.99"Hg
UV index: 0
TueWedThu
72°F / 39°F
70°F / 45°F
57°F / 43°F
Health2 hours ago

The Childhood Illness That Looks Like Slapped Cheeks: What Parents Should Know About Fifth Disease

Interesting Things to Know2 hours ago

Unmarked Police Car Pulling You Over? Here’s What Drivers Should Know

Local News1 day ago

Their Military Service Ended, But Their Commitment to Serving Others Never Did

Interesting Things to Know1 day ago

Route 66 Turns 100: The Highway That Became America’s Mother Road

Local Government2 days ago

Front Royal Calls for Voluntary Water Conservation as Shenandoah River Levels Drop Again

Community Events2 days ago

Salvation Army Kicks Off Red Kettle Campaign in Front Royal, Calling on Community to Ring the Bell

Historically Speaking2 days ago

Constitution 101: Intellectual Property Clause

Obituaries2 days ago

Charles Frederick “Chucki” Henry II (1963 – 2026)

Local News2 days ago

After 164 Years, Young Civil War Soldier Finally Laid to Rest at Arlington National Cemetery

Health2 days ago

The Cheapest Medicare Plan Could Cost You More: Three Things to Check Before December 7

Interesting Things to Know2 days ago

Can Sound Waves Put Out a House Fire? Startup Says Its Technology Could Replace Sprinklers

Local News3 days ago

VDOT: Warren County Traffic Alert for Nov. 9 – 13, 2026

Livestream - WCHS3 days ago

River Rivalry Showdown Tonight: Warren County vs. Skyline Live on Royal Examiner

Local News3 days ago

Virginia Changes Driver’s License Requirements for Young Adults Starting January 1

State News3 days ago

GOP Lawmaker Seeks Senate Investigation, Possible Expulsion of Sen. Louise Lucas

State News3 days ago

At SCC hearing, Virginians say Dominion-NextEra merger could mean higher bills, new risk

Opinion3 days ago

Commentary: In This Year’s Midterms, the Rest of the Country Learned What Virginia Has Known for a While

State News3 days ago

Voter turnout for Virginia’s constitutional amendments transcended partisanship

State News3 days ago

Virginia’s Abortion and Marriage Amendments Face Court Challenges Following Voter Approval

National News3 days ago

Democrats Won Congress. Now They Have to Figure Out How to Deal With Trump

Business Growth Series3 days ago

Business Growth Series: Clear Thinking Leads to More Customers

Community Events3 days ago

Reaching Out Now Brings Back the Old-Fashioned Telethon With a Modern Twist for Giving Tuesday

Interesting Things to Know3 days ago

A Boy, a Marine, and a Christmas Wish List: The 1997 Toys for Tots Commercial Still Touches Hearts

Health3 days ago

Forgetfulness or Alzheimer’s? Warning Signs Families Shouldn’t Ignore

Interesting Things to Know3 days ago

Pulled Over by Police? Why You Shouldn’t Reach for Your License Right Away