Jefferson Forum
Most Virginians Say No to More School Taxes
In October, the Virginia General Assembly’s Joint Subcommittee on K–12 Education Funding took a long-awaited step forward, voting to begin replacing the state’s outdated Standards of Quality (SOQ) school funding formula with a new, student-based model. Gov. Spanberger has likewise pledged to complete the overhaul by the end of her administration.
For nearly two decades, Chris Braunlich and the Jefferson Forum (formerly the Thomas Jefferson Institute) have championed this exact reform. Beginning as early as 2009, Braunlich argued that Virginia’s resource-based SOQ formula – built around rigid staffing ratios, administrative mandates, and central office formulas – was unnecessarily bureaucratic, opaque to taxpayers, and disconnected from students and actual classroom needs.
Unlike the current system, which still puts Virginia among a shrinking minority of just nine states relying on resource-based models, Weighted Student Funding follows the lead of 35 other states by attaching dollars directly to the child. Under this framework, every student generates a base funding amount, with additional weights allocated for specific educational challenges such as poverty, limited English proficiency, or disabilities. As the Jefferson Forum has emphasized, funding students rather than bureaucracies creates transparency, allowing taxpayers and policymakers to see exactly how much money reaches individual schools and whether those investments improve educational outcomes.
Rethinking how Virginia allocates education dollars is a laudable and overdue beginning. However, as lawmakers begin drafting the new formula, they must resist the temptation to treat formula reform as a vehicle for massive new spending – because Virginia voters just delivered a clear verdict on education taxes.
Even as cohorts of voters staunchly supportive of President Trump swung to the Democrats by double-digit margins in the 2026 midterm elections, voters did not embrace a left-wing economic agenda. Ballot initiatives to limit taxes were approved while those that would hike taxes were largely rejected nearly everywhere they were proposed across the country. That includes here in Virginia, where a majority of voters – many of whom voted for a Democrat at the top of the ticket – rebuffed local sales tax hikes for schools.
In California, where Democrat Xavier Becerra won the gubernatorial race by more than 30%, voters rejected a ballot initiative that would have instituted the nation’s first wealth tax. In North Carolina, where voters overwhelmingly supported Democrats across the board, ballot initiatives to cap property tax increases and reduce the state income tax passed with 60% and 62% of the vote, respectively. Iowa voters simultaneously put a Democrat in the governor’s office while establishing a two-thirds supermajority requirement for the legislature to raise income taxes.
The Virginia General Assembly, meanwhile, gave localities the option via the state budget to propose on this year’s ballots a 1% sales tax increase to fund public school infrastructure projects. The proposal was billed as an essential sacrifice by the Virginia Education Association teachers’ union. Voters thought otherwise.
Of the 47 localities where the tax hike was on the ballot, 15 approved and 32 rejected the tax, with 51.7% of voters across those jurisdictions voting no. To put that in perspective, Democrat Mark Warner defeated Republican Burt Mizusawa by a margin of nearly 21% in those same localities, resulting in a 12% split between individuals who voted Democrat while rejecting the school tax.
This split is even more dramatic in several blue localities. In Norfolk, 29,229 voters approved of the tax while 52,390 voted for Warner. In other words, only 44% of Norfolk voters wanted the tax compared to 78% who voted Democrat – a 34% gap. Newport News saw a 31% gap between Warner and the tax initiative. In Chesterfield County, the tax initiative passed by a mere 1,806 votes while Warner won by 44,105, a 42,000-vote split. Even in Richmond, the difference between Warner voters and those who supported the tax hike was 19,503, a 21% gap.
The results of the school tax hike proposal offer state policymakers a key lesson: Education is a bipartisan affordability issue, too – and voters are rejecting calls for more taxes and more spending.
Virginia families, like their peers nationwide, have faced six years of persistently high inflation. The median home price in the state reached $412,000 in 2024, an increase of 40%, or $117,000, since 2019, according to the Virginia Housing Alliance. Since 2024, the price of the median home here has risen another $38,800. Rising property values have brought rising property taxes with them. Grocery prices are up 34% since 2020. Gas prices remain elevated. The list goes on.
Consequently, Virginia voters pegged the cost of living as their top issue going into the midterm election—and they weren’t kidding.
Moving toward Weighted Student Funding is the right structural fix for Virginia’s schools, promising greater transparency and accountability for every dollar spent. Yet as lawmakers build this new system, they must heed the message sent at the ballot box: a bipartisan majority of Virginians have made it clear that whether they are paying for dinner or paying for public schools, their budgets are already stretched too thin.
Key Takeaways:
- Virginia voters rejected higher school taxes. In 47 localities where voters considered a 1% sales tax increase for school construction, 32 rejected the proposal, with 51.7% of voters opposing the tax.
- Opposition to higher taxes crossed party lines. Even in heavily Democratic localities, voters who supported Democratic candidates rejected school tax increases by significant margins.
- School funding reform should prioritize accountability, not spending increases. Virginia’s proposed shift to Weighted Student Funding offers an opportunity to replace an outdated, bureaucratic formula with a more transparent, student-centered system. Lawmakers should focus on ensuring education dollars follow students and produce better outcomes rather than using reform to justify additional taxes.
Michael Torres
Jefferson Forum
Michael Torres is a Fellow at the Jefferson Forum and may be reached at Michael.B.Torres01@gmail.com




