Commentary & Analysis
Commentary: Can Democrats Now Compete for Votes in Republican Rural Virginia?
If Democrats are ever going to win Virginia’s Republican-held 5th, 6th and 9th Congressional Districts, 2026 presented their best chance in decades.
First, they tried changing the boundaries with a mid-decade, statewide gerrymander in response to the same strategy Republicans had already taken in Texas and elsewhere.
Legislative Democrats hastily proposed an amendment to the Virginia Constitution that would have temporarily decommissioned the bipartisan Virginia Redistricting Commission that voters had approved in 2020 to rid their state of partisan reapportionment.
In April, the voters approved the reversal, but the courts nullified it for illegally cutting corners.
Had it gone into effect, the revised districts would have plausibly given Democrats a strong chance to prevail in 10 of Virginia’s 11 U.S. House districts – all but the 9th.
But with the redistricting plan stopped, Democrats entered this month’s election with the next best thing: an intense disapproval of President Donald Trump and a GOP-ruled Congress on which voters placed blame for inflation born of the president’s tariffs and high fuel prices caused by the war Trump launched on Iran.
Democrats won in the most challenging of environments: Texas (a Senate seat and the governor’s office); Kansas (where no Democrat had been elected senator since 1932); and a shocking upset in Mississippi, where Democrat Scott Colom’s Senate victory made him the first African American elected statewide since Reconstruction.
In Virginia, Democrats extended their dominance of the U.S. House delegation from 6-5 to 8-3. They also hold both U.S. Senate seats.
Democrat Tom Perriello fell about 5,748 votes (or 1.5%) shy of Republican U.S. Rep. John McGuire in the 5th District, while fellow Democrats ousted GOP incumbents in the 1st and 2nd districts. Republicans comfortably won reelection in the 6th and 9th districts, respectively.
Outside of another ill-considered redistricting power play, are those districts beyond the Democratic Party’s reach?
Elections are about the conditions the electorate experiences. If they aren’t afraid and struggling, the incumbent usually prospers. If they are, challengers have an advantage, as they did this year.
“From the outset, it was very clear that the main priority for the Republicans in the state was to hold the five districts, that we were not going to be expanding the map beyond that,” Republican Party of Virginia Chairman Jeff Ryer said during After Virginia Votes, a panel discussion sponsored annually by the Virginia Public Access Project and the Schar School of Policy and Government at George Mason University.
GOP resources were focused on holding the most competitive seats — the 1st and 2nd districts. That left strongholds —like the rural 6th and 9th Districts and prohibitive long shots like Bert Mizusawa’s bid to unseat Democratic U.S. Sen. Mark Warner — to fend for themselves, Ryer said.
If things don’t improve in rural Virginia, the path for Republicans gets more challenging.
Trump convincingly won congressional districts in those areas in each of his presidential runs, though he failed to carry Virginia in any of them.
This fall, Republicans in every district — including the 5th, 6th and 9th — significantly underperformed Trump’s 2024 margins but remained strong enough to prevail, according to Virginia Department of Elections data.
Rural Virginia’s economy has been hit particularly hard by Trump and GOP policy actions. If they continue or worsen, Democrats could find a foothold and become competitive, at least in the 5th and 6th districts.
In this year’s midterms, the rest of the country learned what Virginia has known for a while
Zack Golden, a Democratic strategist who managed Warner’s campaign this year, said in his After Virginia Votes appearance that Trump’s policies could eventually “lead to a political realignment in the rural areas.”
“If these gas and diesel prices keep going up … farmers are going to have something to say about that, more than they did in 2026,” he said. “If these Medicaid cuts are continued — are allowed to go into effect — and more rural hospitals close, and people have to drive hours and hours to get healthcare, they’re going to take a second look at their political representation that has allowed this to happen.”
Through the middle of the 20th century, Democratic dominance in those rural areas was unchallenged.
Republicans didn’t gain that dominance overnight. Policies and actions of both parties at the state and federal level fostered it over decades. The same would likely be true for another realignment.
Rural and farming communities also face economic disadvantages resulting from trade policy.
There is a huge disparity compared to urban and suburban Virginia, which are better able to fund schools and attract better employment opportunities. Cuts to Medicaid and Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) benefits disproportionately penalize residents near or below the poverty level in rural areas where good jobs are scarce.
Politicians who listen to those people’s stories and help them can, over time, gain their trust and their votes.
The groundwork for Democratic gains in rural Virginia has been set. The question is whether the party can build on its electoral successes in 2026 with public policies that effectively address rural Virginia’s needs.
By Mark Rozell, Virginia Mercury
Virginia Mercury is part of States Newsroom, a nonprofit news network supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity. Virginia Mercury maintains editorial independence. Contact Editor Samantha Willis with questions: info@virginiamercury.com.
