Connect with us

State News

Herring argues that Congress intended sentencing reform legislation to correct prior injustices, improve public safety, and save taxpayer money

Published

on

RICHMOND (November 23, 2021) – Attorney General Mark R. Herring has joined a coalition of 17 attorneys general in urging the Supreme Court not to restrict the resentencing relief that individuals serving harsh sentences can seek under the First Step Act, landmark criminal justice reform legislation passed by Congress in 2018.

Attorney General Herring and his colleagues filed an amicus brief in Concepcion v. United States, a case concerning what information a court may consider when deciding whether to reduce a harsh sentence for a prior crack cocaine offense under the First Step Act. Specifically, the coalition argues that courts should be able to consider intervening changes to the law since the original sentence was imposed, and intervening changes in a defendant’s factual circumstances, such as good behavior in prison or evidence of rehabilitation. The coalition points to a universal consensus that the former federal sentencing regime, which disproportionately punished crack cocaine offenders over powder cocaine offenders, was unjust and had a disproportionate impact on communities of color. The brief also explains how state-level sentencing reforms analogous to the First Step Act have improved public safety and saved billions of dollars and contends that limiting the scope of the First Step Act would deprive both states and the federal government of similar benefits.

“The passage of the First Step Act helped to create a more fair, just, and equal criminal justice system in this country, and we must ensure that those reforms remain in place,” said Attorney General Herring. “When resentencing eligible Americans under the Act, it’s so important for courts to be able to consider intervening changes in the law or in the individual’s factual circumstances to make the most accurate and fair decision. My top priority will always be to ensure justice, equality, and opportunity in Commonwealth and around the country.”

In the 1980s, states and the federal government responded to the prevalence of crack cocaine and public panic about its supposedly unique dangers with aggressive penalties and targeted criminalization. Federal sentencing laws treated crack cocaine much more harshly than powder cocaine, with 100 times as much powder cocaine as crack cocaine needed to trigger the same penalties.

Harsh penalties for crack cocaine exacerbated racial inequality in the justice system. Historically approximately 60 percent of crack users in a given year have been white, but the majority of people sentenced for crack cocaine offenses have been Black or Hispanic. For example, in 2006, around 80% of those convicted of crack offenses were Black. In part because of dramatically harsher treatment of crack cocaine offenses, the average prison time for Black people convicted of drug offenses increased by more than 77% from 1994 to 2003, compared to an increase of less than 33% for white people convicted of drug offenses.

In 2010, Congress passed the Fair Sentencing Act to reduce the disparity between sentences for crack cocaine and powder cocaine. The First Step Act, a bipartisan criminal justice reform bill passed in 2018, included a provision that made the Fair Sentencing Act’s reforms retroactive, allowing those serving harsh sentences imposed under the former federal law to seek relief.

In their amicus brief filed in Concepcion v. United States, the attorneys general urge the Supreme Court to reverse a lower court’s decision dramatically limiting what courts may consider when resentencing otherwise eligible individuals under the First Step Act. Relying on their historical experience addressing the crack cocaine crisis and their unique authority as the primary enforcers of criminal law, the states argue that during First Step Act resentencing, courts should be allowed to consider intervening changes in the law and facts because:

There is consensus that applying dramatically harsher sentences for crack cocaine offenses over powder cocaine offenses was unnecessary and unjust: When Congress was drafting the First Step Act, states had uniformly concluded that the extreme differential between sentences for crack cocaine and powder cocaine was both unwarranted and unwise. Assumptions about crack cocaine’s unique danger and addictiveness—which informed the original decisions to impose harsher sentences—have been discredited, and there is now widespread consensus that crack cocaine and powder cocaine have similar effects.

Sentencing reform has been shown to improve public safety and save tax dollars: States have experimented with sentencing reforms and reduced sentences for drug-related offenses for decades and have seen these reforms improve public safety, strengthen communities, and decrease recidivism. These reforms have also saved states billions of dollars. Congress passed the First Step Act to realize these benefits at the federal level, and the Act should be interpreted in a manner consistent with that aim.

The First Step Act was intended to right historic wrongs: Congress passed the First Step Act in part to correct fundamental injustices in federal cocaine sentencing laws and address the severe racial disparities created by the prior sentencing regime. Sentencing reform is a powerful tool to help correct the extreme over-incarceration of racial minorities for drug-related crimes and promote racial justice. So far, 96% of those granted sentence reductions under the First Step Act have been Black or Hispanic. It would make little sense to require courts to limit the factors they consider in resentencing and apply old rules no longer on the books—including rules rejected by Congress, the courts, and the Sentencing Commission—when Congress passed the First Step Act specifically to correct the unjust and racially disparate sentences brought on by the old regime.

Joining Attorney General Herring in filing the amicus brief are the attorneys general from Colorado, Colorado, Guam, Illinois, Iowa, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Nevada, New Jersey, New Mexico, North Carolina, Oregon, Vermont, Washington, and the District of Columbia.

Front Royal, VA
34°
Sunny
6:56 am4:58 pm EST
Feels like: 34°F
Wind: 2mph W
Humidity: 97%
Pressure: 30.5"Hg
UV index: 0
TueWedThu
63°F / 32°F
68°F / 32°F
70°F / 36°F
Local News51 minutes ago

Amazon Pledges Millions to Cover In-Demand Career Training at Virginia Community Colleges

Obituaries1 hour ago

Loretta Faye “Cushy” Mullins Roles (1955 – 2026)

Interesting Things to Know2 hours ago

Motorized Hiking Gear Gives Walkers an Extra Boost on the Trail

Food3 hours ago

From Wine Barrels to Ancient Lakebeds: The Surprising Origins of Everyday Baking Ingredients

Local News16 hours ago

Chelsea Academy Lady Knights Capture First State Championship in School History

Obituaries17 hours ago

Pattie Lynn Foster Watkins (1973 – 2026)

Home17 hours ago

The Dirt Your Guests Notice That You Don’t

Interesting Things to Know18 hours ago

Ask Stewart: Tree Stewards Prepare to Celebrate 30 Years of Caring for Our Community

National News1 day ago

States Have 6 More Months to Implement Medicaid Work Requirement, Administration Says

Interesting Things to Know1 day ago

The Dutch Island That Saluted America’s Flag in 1776

Interesting Things to Know1 day ago

Dollywood’s Christmas Schedule Offers Clues to the Busiest Days

Local News2 days ago

Front Royal Winter Shelter Prepares to Open as Social Services Seeks Holiday Help for Local Families

Local News2 days ago

Front Royal Author Brings Irish Folklore to Life with a Talking Dog and a Magical Secret

Historically Speaking2 days ago

Israel: Nation Making

Local News2 days ago

VDOT: Warren County Traffic Alert for Nov. 16 – 20, 2026

Home2 days ago

Thanksgiving Without the Stress: 8 Simple Ways to Enjoy Hosting Your Holiday Dinner

Business2 days ago

Computing Pioneer Found the Secret to Success on a Cross-Country Bicycle Ride

Local Government3 days ago

Initiative, Streamlining, and Industrial Zoning at County Planning Commission Meeting

Obituaries3 days ago

Joyce Catherine Harman (1955 – 2026)

Crime/Court3 days ago

New Facebook Online Post of Supervisor Carter RSW Jail Booking Relates to Earlier Plea Agreement Terms

Obituaries3 days ago

Charles Edison Clatterbuck (1937 – 2026)

Obituaries3 days ago

Richard Lee “Richie” Woodard (1967 – 2026)

State News3 days ago

Virginia Runs $394 Million Ahead of Revenue Forecast Through October

State News3 days ago

Five Virginia Members of Congress Demand State Regulators Deny Dominion-NextEra Merger

State News3 days ago

Virginia Crime Panel Recommends Tougher Penalties for License Plate Reader Misuse, Stops Short of Ban