Cube versus open work space debated

Since the introduction of cubicles to the workplace a half-century ago, the pros and cons of their existence have been well-debated.

But today cubicles are being compared, often favorably and sometimes fondly, to open work spaces.

Open work concepts save floor space and encourage camaraderie, they also convey a false sense of productivity, in which movement and sound translate to only intermittent concentrated quiet, according to the International Facility Management Association.

On the other hand, open work spaces are often most suitable for telecommuting employees who only visit offices occasionally.

But those who work in the open office tell IFMA surveys that privacy is at an all-time low and 74 percent of workers are concerned about it.

The question is whether gains in office communication, brainstorming and camaraderie justify the open space. According to Business News Daily, a cubicle environment can also foster a sense of community, motivation and accountability. Open offices and cubicles also are easier to manage.

Separate office space ranks highest in terms of concentration, privacy, and personalization. But ranks lower in community.