Connect with us

Crime/Court

McDonald attorney – ‘I don’t work for the Afton Inn’

Published

on

The Warren County Courthouse as seen from its new Royal Avenue main entrance side – Royal Examiner File Photos/Roger Bianchini

Also in the Jennifer McDonald-Tom Sayre defamation case motions hearing Wednesday, June 19, Norma Jean Shaw attorney David Downes pointed to a Wednesday morning Josh Gully news story referencing an alleged November 2018 bank wire transfer payment of $10,000 authorized by McDonald to her attorney Lee Berlik’s firm.

Sayre elicits public comment on alleged McDonald embezzlement scheme

Downes reference was made at the hearing’s outset shortly after 11:30 a.m., when Downes alerted the court that opposing “counsel may have a conflict of interest”. Downes explained by pointing to the cited reference to the Cherry Bekaert accounting fraud investigation finding of a November 11, 2018, wire transfer of $10,000 from First Bank & Trust to Berlik Law LLC; a payment authorized by McDonald as a payment to the “Afton Inn Attorney”.

Downes told the court that Berlik “can’t continue to use potentially stolen funds” to pay for his representation of McDonald” adding without suggesting Berlik had previously been aware he may have been paid with stolen funds – “He’s on notice”.

Following Wednesday’s hearing Berlik declined to address the now public Cherry Bekaert allegations against his client; however, outside the courtroom he did tell media present, “I don’t work for the Afton Inn.”

Work on the 151-year-old Afton Inn, at left next door to Town Hall, has been dormant since it was cited in late March civil litigation as a means by which false invoices were alleged to have been created to accomplish illegal wire transfers by the former EDA executive director.

As noted in our above-referenced story the question about whether McDonald might be using allegedly embezzled EDA assets to pay for her civil cases legal representation was first raised by Sands-Anderson attorney Cullen Seltzer during a May 22 EDA civil litigation hearing. That discussion over the status of a plaintiff Discovery Motion request for information on McDonald’s payment of her civil legal fees – a plaintiff motion denied at the time by Judge Clifford L. Athey – came two days before McDonald’s arrest by the Virginia State Police.

The four felony charges McDonald was arrested on – two of Fraud-Obtain Money by False Pretenses and two of Larceny-Embezzlement – related to payments made to credit card companies utilizing what Afton Inn developer 2 East Main Street LLC and Cherry Bekaert assert were fraudulent invoices McDonald created to indicate payments for Afton Inn work.

EDA Attorney accuses former executive director of forging document

After the document purported to be a closed-session resolution signed by the EDA Board of Directors authorizing a 2016, $2-million dollar transfer to its executive director to enact a land purchase was allowed to remain in evidence over the objection of EDA counsel Cullen Seltzer, McDannell was questioned about the document’s origin. After an initial hesitancy telling the judge he did not know the precise origin of the document, McDannell told the court “from my client – she gave me a pile of documents and it was in there with them.”

The following day surviving members of the EDA board whose signatures were on the questioned defense exhibit testified that while it appeared to be their signatures on the closed session authorization of the $2-million for a land transfer to be accomplished by their executive director, they had no recollection of signing such a closed session document.

Roles of McDonald, EDA Board & Goodlatte described at EDA hearing

And so the legal landscape upon which McDonald’s dueling defamation lawsuits with Tom Sayre, as well as her portion of the defense in the EDA civil litigation case seeking recovery of over $21 million in EDA assets, continues to shift seismically for her attorneys at nearly every courtroom step.

Some McDonald assets frozen, jointly-owned exempted in EDA civil case

Physical landscapes, legal landscapes – WHERE are they headed …

Front Royal, VA
63°
Rain Shower
7:03 am4:54 pm EST
Feels like: 63°F
Wind: 0mph N
Humidity: 65%
Pressure: 30.04"Hg
UV index: 2
MonTueWed
64°F / 34°F
50°F / 27°F
50°F / 41°F
Start Your Day With A Smile5 hours ago

Jest A Moment: What if America Had Taken the Turkey Under Its Wing for a National Symbol?

Interesting Things to Know6 hours ago

Overtime Tax Break Gets Easier to Claim in 2026, but Not All Extra Pay Qualifies

Food6 hours ago

The Surprising History Behind Two Thanksgiving Dishes We Think Have Always Been There

Local News24 hours ago

Small Hands, Big Hearts: Young Bell Ringers Bring Christmas Cheer to Front Royal

Historically Speaking1 day ago

Israel: The Fourth Aliyah

Jefferson Forum1 day ago

Taxing Talent and Farmland is Bad Policy for Virginia

Local News1 day ago

Wings of Excellence Academy Turns Holiday Food Drive into Year-Round Mission

Obituaries1 day ago

Maria Lane Himes Miller (1942 – 2026)

Commentary & Analysis1 day ago

JFK & The Woman Who Knew Too Much

Interesting Things to Know1 day ago

Can a Dog Really Have Its Own Smartphone? Meet the PetPhone

Interesting Things to Know1 day ago

How Thanksgiving Leftovers Helped Pave the Way for LASIK Eye Surgery

Obituaries1 day ago

Joyce Bailey Evans (1940 – 2026)

Local Government1 day ago

Cannabis Ordinance Goes Forward with Recommendation of Approval from Town Planning Commission

Local News1 day ago

VDOT: Warren County Traffic Alert for Nov. 23 – Dec. 4, 2026

EDA in Focus1 day ago

Avtex Trail Advisory Subcommittee Emerges at FR-WC EDA Meeting

State News2 days ago

Spanberger Expands Housing Plan Into Three-Year Strategy, Calls for Scrutiny of Corporate Landlords

Local News2 days ago

Front Royal Seeks Applicants for Economic Development Authority Board Vacancy

Local Government2 days ago

Notes from the Front Row: Inside the First Night of Front Royal’s Citizens Academy

State News2 days ago

Virginia Consumers to Receive $4.2 Million in Relief as Attorney General Targets Robocalls and Fraud

Local News2 days ago

Virginia State Police Report Nearly $454,000 in Drug Seizures During Weeklong Operations

Business Growth Series2 days ago

Business Growth Series: Burned-Out Businesses Don’t Grow

Agriculture2 days ago

Virginia Awards $722,000 to Help Farmers Fight Crop Diseases, Improve Food Safety, and Increase Production

Local News2 days ago

Virginia Home Sales Drop Nearly 14% as More Houses Sit on the Market

Community Events2 days ago

From a Front Yard in Maryland to a Bus in Front Royal, Communities Come Together to Fight Hunger

Commentary & Analysis2 days ago

Commentary: Will Virginia Join Other States in Banning a Pesticide Linked to Parkinson’s disease?