Connect with us

National News

US Supreme Court Blocks Trump Rule Limiting Mail Voting, Sides with Dem States

Published

on

The U.S. Supreme Court on Monday kept in place a lower court’s order blocking President Donald Trump’s embattled plan to place new restrictions on mail ballots for this year’s midterm elections.

The unsigned, one-paragraph order upheld a Massachusetts federal court’s injunction on a U.S. Postal Service rule until after Nov. 3 and did not decide whether the rule itself was lawful. But a majority of the court said the Democratic state officials and voting rights groups challenging the rule were likely to succeed.

Two of the court’s stalwart conservatives, Justices Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito, dissented from the decision. Alito wrote that the Postal Service has “broad authority to regulate the mail” and that at this preliminary stage of the suit challenging the rule, its policy should remain in place.

“I express no view on whether the Government would be likely to succeed on de novo review of the Postal Service’s powers,” he wrote. “But for now, the Government has satisfied its burden of making a strong showing that the plaintiff States’ … claim is not likely to succeed.”

In a brief concurrence, Justice Brett Kavanaugh said the rule, which codifies technical requirements on the envelopes carrying ballots and requires states to collect and send to the federal government lists of eligible voters, may be legal, but was unworkable for the midterm elections 50 days away.

“There is at least a fair prospect that the final rule falls within the Postal Service’s statutory authority,” he wrote. “But applying the rule in the 2026 elections would be arbitrary and capricious …  because state and local election officials do not have sufficient time to reasonably implement the rule before the elections.”

The rule’s challengers argued, in part, that the regulations would be impossible to install ahead of Election Day. Several election administrators, pro-democracy groups and others declared to the court that they agreed with that argument.

The Postal Service did not bring any evidence against those claims.

Democrats and voting rights advocates also argued the rule was illegal and unconstitutional. The executive branch has virtually no role in election administration, which is a state responsibility with congressional oversight under the U.S. Constitution, they said.

The case, tried before President Barack Obama appointee U.S. District Judge Indira Talwani, will continue to evaluate the legality of the rule for future elections.

Challengers react

The groups and officials challenging the rule, as well as other Democrats, hailed the ruling in statements.

“Today’s order from our nation’s highest court makes clear that states cannot be forced to undermine their mail voting systems and risk voter disenfranchisement because of the President’s political agenda,” Massachusetts Attorney General Joy Campbell said. “Mail voting is safe, secure, and reliable, and I will continue to stand up for Massachusetts residents who rely on mail ballots to ensure that they can have their voices heard in the November election.”

Virginia Kase Solomón, the president and CEO of Common Cause, one of the groups suing to block the rule, called the decision “a major win for the millions of everyday Americans,” including elderly and rural voters, and those with disabilities, who depend on vote-by-mail.

“This executive order was a blatant power grab designed to silence voters and undermine our elections, but it failed because the people and the law were on our side,” she said in a statement. “Our Constitution is clear: states run our elections, and voters choose their leaders—not the other way around. No administration can strip the people of their power.”

California Gov. Gavin Newsom, whose state was the lead plaintiff in the case, said the rule was part of Trump’s “attacks on democracy” for the past 20 months.

“California stood up for democracy, and we won,” Newsom wrote on social media. “Today is a good day for democracy, the rule of law, and the American people looking to exercise their Constitutional right to vote.”

Phil Weiser, Colorado’s attorney general and Democratic nominee for governor, said the court “just sent the message that President Trump and the Postal Service need to stay the hell away from our elections.”

California and Colorado are among the eight states that send ballots to every registered voter.

Spokespeople for the White House, Postal Service and U.S. Department of Justice, which represented the administration in the case, did not respond to emails seeking comment late Monday.

In the hour following the ruling, Trump posted on his social media platform in opposition to slowing artificial intelligence development, the poor condition of the Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts building and his promise to send every voter $5,000 if Republicans win the upcoming midterms, but did not address the ruling.

 

by Jacob Fischler, Virginia Mercury


Virginia Mercury is part of States Newsroom, a nonprofit news network supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity. Virginia Mercury maintains editorial independence. Contact Editor Samantha Willis with questions: info@virginiamercury.com.

Front Royal, VA
70°
Showers in the Vicinity
6:44 am5:08 pm EST
Feels like: 70°F
Wind: 4mph S
Humidity: 87%
Pressure: 29.86"Hg
UV index: 0
FriSatSun
72°F / 43°F
57°F / 43°F
64°F / 45°F
Local News3 hours ago

Front Royal Named 2026 Top Adventure Town by Blue Ridge Outdoors Magazine

Local Government4 hours ago

County Supervisors Get Overview of Inland Port Benefits, Review Town/County MOU on Future Tourism Initiatives

Local News4 hours ago

Front Royal High School Seniors Can Apply for $3,000 Electric Utility Scholarship

Local Government5 hours ago

Retaining Wall Variance Under Close Scrutiny at Town Planning Commission Work Session

Local Government10 hours ago

Warren County Schools to End Parent Walk-Ins During Morning Drop-Off Beginning January 6

State News10 hours ago

Virginia Voters Split on 1% Sales Tax for School Construction

Local Government11 hours ago

Warren County Schools Unveils Five-Year Strategic Plan, But Board Members Want Building Maintenance and Academic Results Added

Mature Living13 hours ago

Staying Strong After 50: How Movement Specialists Can Help You Stay Active and Independent

Home13 hours ago

Does a Second Paycheck Really Pay? Why Earning More Doesn’t Always Mean Keeping More

Local Government23 hours ago

Warren County Schools Outlines Fast-Track Plan for E. Wilson Morrison Structural Investigation

National News1 day ago

The Election Is Over. What’s Supposed to Happen Next for Congress?

State News1 day ago

Spanberger Saw a Path to Four House Flips. Democrats Have Won Two

Obituaries1 day ago

Myrtland Hugh “Myrt” Haden (1939 – 2026)

Community Events1 day ago

Every Ring Helps a Neighbor: Front Royal Salvation Army Kicks Off Red Kettle Campaign on November 7

State News1 day ago

Warner Wins Fourth Term, Luria Ousts Kiggans in VA-02, Taylor Triumphs in VA-01

Obituaries1 day ago

Wayne Mitchell Smoot (1949 – 2026)

Opinion1 day ago

Are Warren County Officials Really Conserving the Dollars of the Citizen Taxpayers?

Local News1 day ago

The Courage to Begin: Browntown Songwriter Roger Tomhave Earns National Recognition for Inspirational Song

State News1 day ago

Dominion-NextEra Accept Some Proposed Protections in Merger Case, Rejects Rate and Staffing Freeze

Interesting Things to Know2 days ago

Your Will May Not Decide Who Gets Your Money: One Overlooked Form Could Change Everything

Local News2 days ago

Blue Ridge Wildlife Center Patient of the Week: North American River Otter

Community Events2 days ago

This Week’s Showtimes at Royal Cinemas as of November 5th

arrest logo
Arrest Logs2 days ago

POLICE: 7 Day FRPD Arrest Report 11/2/2026

Local News2 days ago

Front Royal Incumbents Lead Election Results as Warren County Rejects All Three Constitutional Amendments

Local News2 days ago

Ever Wonder How Front Royal Runs? Citizens Academy Opens Applications for New Class