EDA Acknowledges Failure of Attempted 158 Faith Way $350,000 Deed Buy-Back – What Happened?

On the morning of Tuesday, April 2, a press release from Warren County Director of Economic Development Joe Petty announced the failure of the previously announced Economic Development Authority (EDA, FR-WC EDA) acceptance of a deed buy-back offer of $350,000 by Jennifer McDonald and her husband, Samuel North, on their home property at 158 Faith Way. This reporter found that press release somewhat vague on exactly why the buy-back arrangement had failed. Readers will recall from our below-referenced story that the McDonald/North deed buy-back would have likely netted the EDA, and indirectly the County, at least $150,000 more than a resale effort after maintaining the earlier-announced property seizure.

The center of attention in the now-failed attempt to gain maximum profit for the EDA and County through a deed sell-back of the McDonald/North home property. Below, County Director of Economic Development and the County’s chief liaison to their now unilaterally overseen EDA, Joe Petty, addresses EDA budget variables at the March 26 supervisors meeting. Royal Examiner File Photos

The opening paragraph of the April 2 release offered a hint about unmet terms: “On March 22, 2024, the Front Royal-Warren County Economic Development Authority (EDA) Board of Directors held a regularly scheduled meeting during which it approved a settlement offer with Jennifer McDonald and Samuel North regarding property located at 158 Faith Way. McDonald and North had deeded title to the EDA on February 5, 2024, but not vacated, thus requiring ongoing significant and costly EDA and Warren County litigation. As the terms of that offer were not met by McDonald/North, on March 28, 2024, the EDA Board of Directors held a special meeting and voted to rescind its March 22nd resolution and withdraw the offer.”

“Not met” in what way we wondered, and decided to ask EDA Board Chairman Jd Walter. He replied to our emailed inquiry, explaining: “Almost immediately upon EDA approval, their (McDonald/North) counsel advised EDA counsel that they would not be able to meet the payment schedule. Subsequently, North did not withdraw his appeal of the order of possession, which was another term of the settlement offer. As such, the EDA considered the offer not accepted, thus voted to rescind its previous resolution and withdraw the offer.”

The EDA Board of Directors has been busy trying to attain maximum value from, initially, a property seizure, then a deed sell-back to EDA ‘financial scandal’ central figure Jennifer McDonald and her husband Samuel North’s home property. The latest announcement was not good for achieving maximum value, as the couple did not meet deed buy-back conditions.

So, what is the status of the McDonald-North home property at this point? “The EDA is awaiting a hearing in Circuit Court on the North appeal to the order of possession. Until that hearing is concluded, the EDA cannot take physical possession of the property,” Chairman Walter explained.

So, it appears that the EDA is back to taking possession of the property with all its negative financial implications regarding legal fees, liens filed against the property by third parties, an unpaid $250,000 mortgage equal to half the value of the property, not to mention closing costs on any prospective sale.

Well, based on their comments against the deed resale effort at the March 26 supervisors meeting it would seem that at least the five elected members of the Warren County Board of Supervisors are happy — though this reporter remains baffled as to exactly why.

(See LINKED Royal Examiner story: “EDA Plan to return McDonald-North Home Property Deed for $350,000 Cash Raises Ire of Supervisors – But What Do the Numbers say?”)

Below is the full April 2nd Press Release on the canceled Faith Way deed resale effort:

On March 22, 2024, the Front Royal-Warren County Economic Development Authority (EDA) Board of Directors held a regularly scheduled meeting during which it approved a settlement offer with Jennifer McDonald and Samuel North regarding property located at 158 Faith Way. McDonald and North had deeded title to the EDA on February 5, 2024, but not vacated, thus requiring ongoing significant and costly EDA and Warren County litigation. As the terms of that offer were not met by McDonald/North, on March 28, 2024, the EDA Board of Directors held a special meeting and voted to rescind its March 22nd resolution and withdraw the offer.

The proposed settlement terms were for McDonald/North to pay the EDA, by certified check a cash settlement of $350,000.00 and to withdraw North’s appeal of an order of possession of the Faith Way property granted to the EDA on March 6, 2024, by the Warren County Circuit Court. For these terms, the EDA would have deeded the property back to McDonald/North. In such a case, the multiple liens against the property by parties outside of the EDA would have remained the responsibility of McDonald/North, and not been a deduction from the proceeds to the EDA if the EDA sold the property.

As noted, the EDA received an order of possession for the 158 Faith Way property on March 6th. However, because North has appealed that decision the EDA cannot yet take physical possession of the property in order to sell it for fair market value. Upon sale of the property, the EDA will be required to satisfy the multiple liens against the property and cover closing costs.

The EDA takes very seriously the perspectives of the community as it relates to matters associated with McDonald and her actions as former Executive Director of the EDA. The EDA Board’s decision of March 22nd made sound financial sense. It was not accepted. The EDA wants to make clear because of their serious, negative impacts on the community, McDonald/North are not entitled to the positive consideration of being allowed to stay in their home when their size-able debt to the EDA, County and community remains unpaid.

The next regular monthly EDA Board meeting will be held on Friday, April 26, 2024, at 8:00 AM, at the Warren County Government Center.

EDA Plan to Return McDonald-North Home Property Deed for $350,000 Cash Raises Ire of Supervisors – But What Do the Numbers Say? – Royal Examiner