Connect with us

EDA in Focus

McDonald bankruptcy filing removes her from EDA civil suit – July 2022 dates set for remaining civil defendants’ trial

Published

on

The Front Royal-Warren County Economic Development Authority civil litigation now seeking about $26 million in asset recovery against 24 defendants including its former executive director was dealt a harsh blow the day before scheduled motions hearings Friday morning, September 25. That blow was a notice of former EDA Executive Director Jennifer McDonald’s Chapter 7 bankruptcy filing Thursday afternoon, September 24.

As noted in the filing and as discussed in Warren County Circuit Courtroom “A” Friday, the bankruptcy filing essentially removes McDonald from the civil litigation process. McDonald’s bankruptcy filing included one of her two real estate companies, MoveOn8 LLC.

“As a result of the institution of the bankruptcy proceeding, all actions to collect a debt from Jennifer McDonald, or to recover property from the bankruptcy estate of Jennifer McDonald, have been stayed by reason of the applicability of Section 362(a) of the United States Bankruptcy Code (11 U.S.C. 362(A)),” McDonald attorney Peter Greenspun wrote in the filing received in the Warren County Circuit Court Clerk’s Office Thursday afternoon. The same holds true as to a stay on asset recovery in the MoveOn8 LLC filing.

Jennifer McDonald’s Thursday bankruptcy filing has essentially STOPPED her involvement in the $26-million EDA civil litigation swirling around her alleged embezzlements. Royal Examiner Photos by Roger Bianchini

With EDA lead attorney Cullen Seltzer acknowledging the stay on civil action against McDonald involving her now bankruptcy-trustee seized assets, a scheduled 9 a.m. motions hearing seeking financial sanctions against her for attempting to move a piece of property frozen by the court near the outset of the April 2019 EDA civil litigation filing was removed from the docket. Judge Bruce D. Albertson adjourned the 9 a.m. proceedings 10 minutes after they began.

Motions hearings on the remaining defendants’ cases commenced shortly after 10 a.m. as scheduled. Two defense attorneys connected by remote audio hookup told the court they were likely to file similar “interlocutory appeals” motions to the one April Petty and Jesse Poe attorney William Shmidheiser informed the court in person he would be filing. Those petitions will seek to have defendants removed from the single “mass trial” the plaintiff is seeking in alleging a wide-ranging conspiracy of McDonald and associates to profit from the alleged McDonald-directed embezzlements and misdirection of EDA assets.

Before making his case that his clients should be removed from the single trial of all defendants, as the 10 a.m. hearing began Shmidheiser called McDonald’s bankruptcy “the elephant in the room” that should be discussed with all involved defense attorneys linked in. That led EDA attorney Seltzer to repeat his acknowledgment that the case against primary defendant McDonald was stayed from further action due to the bankruptcy process.

Several times during subsequent discussion McDonald was referred to as “the hub” of the conspiracy “wheel” the plaintiff is alleging existed between the former EDA executive director and those believed to have benefitted financially one way or another from her alleged misdirection and embezzlement of EDA assets.

While criminal charges related to the EDA civil suit have been dropped against McDonald and others due to speedy trial statute concerns, the threat of refiling remains, leading to possible invocation of 5th Amendment rights if called to testify or be deposed in other defendants’ cases.

Former EDA and McDonald Administrative Assistant Michelle Henry’s attorney John Cook told the court the McDonald bankruptcy filing made his client’s case problematic, in that Henry has filed to force McDonald to pay for her legal fees in the civil case.

Also on the table Friday was McDonald’s ability or willingness to testify as a witness as the civil cases proceed in the wake of her bankruptcy filing. That she could be deposed as a witness in other cases seemed agreed upon. But whether she would quickly choose to invoke her 5th Amendment right not to self-incriminate, with the refiling of criminal charges also still a possibility, remained at issue.

Judge Albertson took defense counsel concerns about the bankruptcy filing’s impact on the other defendant’s cases under advisement, observing, “I think we can proceed with (setting) dates in the event I rule the stay is not warranted.”

EDA attorney Seltzer noted the large number of witnesses to be deposed, over 50 he acknowledged; as well as the limited days per month, three, available for those depositions, depositions he predicted would at a minimum take a full day due to the number of defendants and their counsel involved. Due to those factors, coupled with lingering pandemic limitations on court processes, Seltzer raised an eyebrow or two predicting the civil trial wouldn’t happen before July of 2022.

That prediction led to an added sense of urgency by Petty and Jesse Poe’s attorney. Responding to a question, Shmidheiser told the court he probably would file his interlocutory appeal by the end of the week, as he sought a November date for a hearing on the appeal. Judge Albertson set November 23, at 3:30 p.m., for what is anticipated to be a 30 to 40 minute or so hearing.

Shmidheiser also told Judge Albertson that one of his primary hopes for the day’s hearing was that specific dates would be set for the lengthy deposition process of witnesses, as opposed to the vague “three days a month” tag currently on the table. Agreeing that pinning down dates for depositions was a preferred course of action, Albertson set about finding dates all attorneys could be available for.

Due to varying attorney’s schedules, preferences and other court variables, Tuesdays-Wednesdays-and-Thursdays were set between January and May 2021 to get the deposition ball rolling. Deposition dates agreed to were January 13-14-15; February 16-17-18; March 30, 31, April 1; and May 11-12-13.

Acknowledging the process would likely continue through the remainder of the year, Albertson set a pre-trial motions date of February 19, with a 24-day trial scheduled 4-1/2 months later from July 5 to 29, 2022.

Some of us may need an ambulance to get to the EDA civil trial now scheduled for 24 days in July of 2022.

Seltzer did acknowledge it was possible some defendants’ motions to be removed to individual trials could be successful, leading to earlier trials for those defendants.

As for the bankruptcy situation, one attorney present familiar with bankruptcy cases, later explained to the media that the EDA could file to have certain McDonald assets separated from the bankruptcy sale process to accommodate creditors, citing her alleged embezzlements. However, without a conviction in support of those allegations that filing might be hard to get approved by a bankruptcy trustee, Shmidheiser said. He added that the bankruptcy transfers McDonald’s liability from the EDA civil case now in Warren County Circuit Court to a judge-overseen trial in a Harrisonburg U.S. Western District of Virginia Bankruptcy Court.

According to the McDonald Bankruptcy Docket posted by the U.S. Western District of Virginia Court:

The First Meeting of Creditors is scheduled for 9 a.m. on Friday, November 13, 2020 (by telephone);

Deadline for filing Proofs of Claims has not yet been set, because McDonald filed her case as a “No Asset Case”;

Deadline for filing Complaints for Exception to Bankruptcy Discharge is Tuesday, January 12, 2021. The Warren EDA will have to file a Complaint for Exception to Discharge case by the deadline, or its claim will be discharged in bankruptcy, we were told;

McDonald ‘s Bankruptcy Schedules are due to be filed by October 8, 2020 – but if time extensions are requested, they are generally liberally granted.

The Trustee is listed as Bob Stevens of Charlottesville, along with the Office of the U.S. Trustee, with a Roanoke address.

Front Royal, VA
59°
Sunny
6:57 am4:57 pm EST
Feels like: 59°F
Wind: 0mph WNW
Humidity: 38%
Pressure: 30.51"Hg
UV index: 2
WedThuFri
68°F / 32°F
72°F / 34°F
72°F / 36°F
Community Events4 hours ago

Dance Club Shenandoah Celebrates 60 Years of Music, Dancing, and Friendship

State News5 hours ago

Virginia Lawmakers Weigh Using Marijuana Taxes to Fund School Substance Use Programs

Punditry & Prose6 hours ago

Commentary: Getting Back to Virginia Amid the FAA Chaos Wasn’t ‘The Odyssey,’ But It Certainly Was a Pain

State News6 hours ago

FAA Ground Stop Disrupts 532 Flights at 4 Virginia Airports

National News6 hours ago

US Loses Its ‘Measles Elimination Status’ After More Than 25 Years

Interesting Things to Know7 hours ago

Your Boss Sees Your Work. But Does Your Industry Know What You Can Do?

Health8 hours ago

When the Weight Comes Back: What Happens After You Stop Taking GLP-1 Drugs?

Local Government21 hours ago

Gazebo Park Trees Battle a Contagious and Often Fatal Black Mold Infection

Opinion23 hours ago

Virginia Families Are Losing an Opportunity. And for What?

Local News1 day ago

Amazon Pledges Millions to Cover In-Demand Career Training at Virginia Community Colleges

Obituaries1 day ago

Loretta Faye “Cushy” Mullins Roles (1955 – 2026)

Interesting Things to Know1 day ago

Motorized Hiking Gear Gives Walkers an Extra Boost on the Trail

Food1 day ago

From Wine Barrels to Ancient Lakebeds: The Surprising Origins of Everyday Baking Ingredients

Local News2 days ago

Chelsea Academy Lady Knights Capture First State Championship in School History

Obituaries2 days ago

Pattie Lynn Foster Watkins (1973 – 2026)

Home2 days ago

The Dirt Your Guests Notice That You Don’t

Interesting Things to Know2 days ago

Ask Stewart: Tree Stewards Prepare to Celebrate 30 Years of Caring for Our Community

National News2 days ago

States Have 6 More Months to Implement Medicaid Work Requirement, Administration Says

Interesting Things to Know2 days ago

The Dutch Island That Saluted America’s Flag in 1776

Interesting Things to Know2 days ago

Dollywood’s Christmas Schedule Offers Clues to the Busiest Days

Local News3 days ago

Front Royal Winter Shelter Prepares to Open as Social Services Seeks Holiday Help for Local Families

Local News3 days ago

Front Royal Author Brings Irish Folklore to Life with a Talking Dog and a Magical Secret

Historically Speaking3 days ago

Israel: Nation Making

Local News3 days ago

VDOT: Warren County Traffic Alert for Nov. 16 – 20, 2026

Home3 days ago

Thanksgiving Without the Stress: 8 Simple Ways to Enjoy Hosting Your Holiday Dinner