Connect with us

EDA in Focus

Town, County officials tread lightly around the elephant in the room



As Liaison Chair Bill Sealock listens, Council Clerk Jennifer Berry records and Councilwoman Letasha Thompson jots notes, Town Manager Joe Waltz, center right, takes his turn updating county officials across the table on the status of a variety of town projects. Royal Examiner Photos/Roger Bianchini

With a rising tide of critical public scrutiny of past failures of municipal oversight of the Town-County Economic Development Authority resulting in civil litigation involving an attempt to recover nearly $20 million in misdirected assets at a cost of over three-quarters-of-a-million dollars of taxpayer money; and concurrent criminal investigations stretching to the federal level, one might think a quarterly Town-County Liaison Committee meeting might be rife with discussion of that topic.

However both the town and county governments conduct other business – and as they say on Broadway, “the show must go on”.

So the first 20 minutes of a brief 30 minutes or less Front Royal-Warren County Liaison Committee meeting of Thursday, April 18, was devoted to summary briefings of that other business. Town Manager Joe Waltz and County Administrator Doug Stanley handled presentation of those summaries offered to committee members Bill Sealock and Letasha Thompson on the town side and Dan Murray and Tony Carter representing the County.

With the Town taking on the rotating hosting duties, Vice-Mayor Sealock chaired his second meeting during Mayor Hollis Tharpe’s self-imposed administrative leave pending resolution of a misdemeanor criminal charge involving a massage parlor visit. See Related Story:

Topics on the Town side included:

  1. the status of Phase One of the West Main Street Extended Project into the ITFederal portion of the Royal Phoenix Business Park from Kendrick Lane – 90% complete to the first building constructed on site;
  2. construction of a parallel central water utility line into the Route 522/340 North Commercial-Industrial Corridor – a May 6 submission for updated plan evaluation and cost estimates;
  3. the Town’s halting movement toward enforcement of a property maintenance code that will initially target only blighted and derelict structures – awaiting County feedback on a request to utilize the County’s Board of Building Code Appeals as a more cost efficient method of that implementation;
  4. resolution of infrastructure issues at a new wastewater treatment plant septage receiving station – accomplished and backflow issues resolved;
  5. and the status of Phases 2 and 3 of the Happy Creek Road Project – $1.3 million in carryover VDOT funds transferred for use on Phase 2; another $2.5 million committed by the EDA for the project, with a total cost estimate of $16.9 million for both phases and a projected 2026 start date.

On the County side topics included:

As Tony Carter, center left, listens and Dan Murray’s hand, bottom left, occupies, County Administrator Doug Stanley takes his turn updating town officials on county projects, some within the town limits.

  1. the Crooked Run West developer request for Town central water service extension into the County’s North Corridor – County Planning Commission recommendation of denial of necessary zoning changes to facilitate a 1000-plus residential unit mixed development project that is contrary to both county and town comprehensive plan guidelines; recent receipt of a VDOT traffic study; and June as the earliest estimate of county board of supervisors discussion of whether or not to adhere to its planning commission recommendation of denial of the project;
  2. Development Review Committee projects – met on March 27 to discuss the Crooked Run West proposal, as well as construction of a new Christendom College chapel, Catlett Mountain Road home construction on existing lots; and in-town projects including an ice vendor business on South Royal Avenue; a daycare on South Commerce Avenue; a proposed Sheetz Gas Station on Shenandoah Avenue; and interior work on A. S. Rhodes Elementary School. The committee’s next meeting is slated for April 24;
  3. the status of the EnerGov building inspection software upgrades designed to make online self service a customer friendly experience. The status of that software system that initially went live on November 14, 2017, is continued issues to resolve what was discovered to “not provide the public a friendly experience” and discussion with an outside contractor to correct the situation in more timely manner than county staff could accomplish it;
  4. the County’s project inside the town limits, including Ressie Jeffries Elementary School renovations – completed; upgrades to the Health and Human Services building on 15th Street to accommodate occupancy by the County Registrar’s Office – moved in April 1; and the public school system’s Brighter Futures alternative school program – completed in November; punch list review with contractor under way;
  5. implementation of the joint town-county tow board – establishment of a tow list of qualified companies on February 6 that will be in effect through June 30, 2020. Citizen complaints were heard about exorbitant tow costs, a main issue surrounding creation of the town board, at an April 3 tow board meeting. However, such complaints have apparently not been officially submitted to the tow board in writing. So, Stanley’s summary indicated “tow representatives” are urging citizens to file official complaint forms which are available online. Contact the county administrator’s office for further detail on accessing those forms.

The elephant in the room

With the above agenda discussion completed by 6:20 p.m., Vice-Mayor Sealock asked if there was any other business to be brought forward. County Board Supervisor Carter noted that the county had agreed to take over as fiscal agent for the EDA, effective August 1.

County Board Chairman Murray noted that the County’s assumption of that role will provide “multiple layers of checks and balances” of EDA financial workings. On the EDA side their board has created redundancies in requiring the signatures of two board members on financial transactions, as well as increased board involvement in the development of those transactions.

From left, EDA Board Chairman Gray Blanton, EDA Board member Ron Llewellyn, term expired and since resigned, and then-Executive Director Jennifer McDonald at a November 2018 town council work session; the following month McDonald resigned amidst a mounting EDA financial crisis. Royal Examiner File Photo

As for the increased checks and balances provided by putting the EDA under the fiscal agent auspices of county government, a previous county staff presentation cited direct involvement of the County Finance Department and Treasurer’s Office in procurement policy, bookkeeping and recordkeeping of EDA business. The down side acknowledged is the additional demand on county staff to assume those additional responsibilities for another agency.

But in the current and still evolving legal and political environment it appears that additional demand will be a necessary consequence to assist in putting the EDA’s house back in order; not to mention a step in regaining the trust of what is becoming an increasingly suspicious, and according to Dan Murray, aggressively hostile public. As noted in a related Royal Examiner  video, at Tuesday’s county board meeting Murray described being physically pushed Sunday at a diner he regularly frequents by a customer angry about the EDA situation.

And so things progress this spring of 2019, as municipal and EDA officials wrestle with how they allowed what is alleged to have happened within the EDA in recent years happen; and how they will respond to what appears to be a growing social media-fed negative public reaction of a sometimes less than constructive nature.

County Board Chairman Dan Murray at April 17 capital improvements bond issue signing with EDA officials; EDA Board Vice-Chairman Bruce Drummond, standing, waits for the paperwork to slide his way.

Share the News:


McDonald criminal plea hearing postponed



The anticipated entry of pleas on the initial 12 felony criminal financial charges against Jennifer McDonald did not occur on Monday, July 15, due to judicial recusal. Royal Examiner File Photo/Roger Bianchini

The entry of pleas to the 12 felony criminal charges of embezzlement or fraudulent misdirection of EDA assets by former Front Royal-Warren County Economic Development Authority Executive Director Jennifer McDonald has been put off to a yet-to-be determined date. McDonald’s plea hearing was scheduled as part of the 9 a.m. docket on the July Grand Jury-Term Day on Monday, July 15.

However newly-seated Circuit Court Judge William W. Sharpe, who is moving from Domestic Relations Court to replace Judge Clifford L. Athey Jr. who is taking a seat on the Virginia Appeals Court on September 1, entered a written recusal from EDA-related cases on Friday, July 12. In the wake of that recusal notice neither McDonald nor her criminal attorney Peter Greenspun were in court Monday. McDonald was transferred from RSW Regional Jail to the Fairfax Adult Detention Center on June 11. Greenspun’s office is in Fairfax.

In his recusal Sharpe writes, “It is necessary for this judge to recuse from all cases that may relate to the Warren County Economic Development Authority and Jennifer McDonald, in order to ensure that all parties can be confident the judge has no association with any persons who might be involved in a particular case, either as parties or a witness.”

Sharpe prefaces that statement by pointing out that, “a number of persons who are named as defendants in the pending EDA civil action against Jennifer McDonald and other parties, as well as members of the EDA Board and persons who it appears may be material witnesses in the civil action filed by the EDA, as well as other related civil actions or filed and possible criminal proceedings arising out of the same transactions, are personal friends or former clients or persons with whom the judge has otherwise had regular associations.”

In fact this reporter ran into Judge Athey outside the courthouse on Friday, July 12. During a brief conversation about the coming week’s EDA-related hearings Athey explained that he would be fazed out of the EDA hearings equation during the coming week to accommodate both his pending move to the state appeals court and the transfer of judicial authority over the EDA civil and criminal cases to other 26th Judicial District judges.

Athey was aware of Sharpe’s recusal and even commented that had he not been moving off the Warren County bench as the EDA cases progressed toward evidentiary hearings and trial he likely would also have recused for similar reasons to those stated by Sharpe, personal or professional familiarity with involved parties. He said he felt it acceptable to hear early motions prior to evidentiary testimony becoming involved in order to keep the cases moving forward in their early stages.

Athey’s primary rulings thus far have been to deny McDonald bond as a flight risk in her criminal cases and an order that EDA civil counsel produce the evidentiary basis for what is a currently a nine-defendant civil suit seeking recovery of a total of over $21-million dollars. That order led to the release into court files of public accounting firm Cherry Bekaert’s “working papers” from its contracted investigation of indicators of financial fraud in EDA operations.

Above, former EDA Executive Director Jennifer McDonald was arrested by Virginia State Police on May 24, making her the first person to face criminal charges stemming from the EDA fraud investigation. McDonald’s Administrative Assistant Michelle ‘Missy’ Henry, below, was the second person arrested in the case. Henry has been jailed since June 24 awaiting a once-delayed bond hearing. Photos RSW website

On Monday Assistant Commonwealth’s Attorney Bryan Layton said it was unclear how the coming judicial appointments might impact other scheduled EDA hearings this week. Motions in the EDA civil action are scheduled for the 9 a.m. docket Wednesday, July 17 and former EDA Administrative Assistant Michelle “Missy” Henry’s already once-delayed bond hearing is scheduled on the 9 a.m. docket Friday, July 19.

Henry was arrested by VSP on sealed special grand jury indictments on June 24. Retired substitute Judge Thomas Horne deferred a decision on bond for Henry on June 25, citing his unfamiliarity with the case. It now remains unclear if the ongoing judicial juggling may again delay a bond decision for Henry this week.

The Warren County Special Grand Jury empanelled to investigate potential criminality connected to the EDA civil case is also scheduled to meet through the latter part of the week.
In a not directly-related criminal case, former Front Royal Mayor Hollis Tharpe has a motions hearing scheduled Monday afternoon at 2:30 p.m. on his solicitation of prostitution misdemeanor case.

Ranking presiding 26th Judicial District Judge Bruce D. Albertson will be responsible for appointing judges to hear EDA-related cases that Sharpe has recused himself from. According to the Virginia Judicial website, active 26th District judges besides Sharpe and the soon-to-be-departed Athey, include Clark A. Ritchie, Kevin C. Black, Alexander R. Iden and Thomas J. Wilson.

However, it is possible Judge Albertson could appoint another substitute judge, including retired court officers who still help the district fill its judicial requirements when shortages and recusals occur.

Share the News:
Continue Reading

EDA in Focus

EDA Investigation Series Parts 9 – Bianchini 2nd interview



Lt Landin Waller interviews Roger Bianchini again.

In the second of two Front Royal Police interviews with yours truly, Royal Examiner reporter and editorial consultant Roger Bianchini on June 16, 2017, investigators Landin Waller and Crystal Cline revisit information given them in his initial interview around 10:45 a.m. that morning.

In the interim between the two interviews FRPD investigators have learned from the Warren County Sheriff’s Office that the rock-throwing vandalism Bianchini reported being told about by Jennifer McDonald the previous afternoon, had been reported by McDonald as occurring around 9 p.m. the previous evening. That was some five to six hours after Bianchini said the EDA executive director described the front-door vandalism of her home to him, leading him to believe the incident had occurred over the course of the previous week.

In interview two, Episode 9 of Royal Examiner’s series of FRPD investigative interview videos Bianchini returns around 3 p.m. to confirm the information given to investigators that Friday morning.

Perhaps ironically, McDonald’s lengthy FRPD interview concerning the EDA office break in, separated into three parts in this series, occurred Thursday afternoon, June 15, 2017, between 1:15 p.m. and 2:56 p.m., just prior to the meeting in her office Bianchini would to describe to FRPD the following morning.

Reference FRPD’s June 16, 2017, interview with EDA Marketing Director Marla Jones (Episode 7) in which Jones corroborates Bianchini’s story that he had a lengthy, closed door meeting with McDonald mid-afternoon, Thursday, June 15, and was not at the EDA office the morning of Friday, June 16, to be informed of the vandalism as McDonald attorney David Crump asserted he was during McDonald’s misdemeanor Filing a False Police Report trial of October 31, 2018. Jones’ interview was conducted around 1 p.m., between the two Bianchini interviews of June 16, 2017.

For some reason the prosecution did not call Jones to corroborate their main witness Bianchini’s story, though she was present to be called that Halloween Day and her FRPD interview was available to the prosecution. Also uncalled to testify at that trial that saw McDonald acquitted without having to present a defense were the FRPD officers who developed the false police report case.

As noted in the preface to Bianchini’s morning interview (Episode 8) video, in the coming year and a half the EDA executive director would come under increasing scrutiny by multiple levels of law enforcement, as well as by the Town of Front Royal, and eventually the County and her own EDA Board of Directors, culminating with her December 20, 2018 resignation; as well as apparent written acceptance of responsibility for the return of $2.7 million in misdirected EDA assets McDonald remains jailed without bond as a flight risk in the Fairfax Adult Detention Center, where she was transferred from RSW Regional Jail on June 11. She was arrested by Virginia State Police on four felony counts of fraud or embezzlement of EDA assets on May 24, 2019. She will be in court Monday, July 15, to enter pleas on those initial charges, and possibly on eight related financial felony counts she was served with on June 21.

Share the News:
Continue Reading

EDA in Focus

2017 EDA Investigation Part 8: FRPD questions Royal Examiner Reporter Roger Bianchini



Roger Bianchini is interviewed by FRPD Lt Landin Waller

FRONT ROYAL – Following the May 18, 2017 reported break-in at the Front Royal-Warren County EDA office located at 400-D Kendrick Lane, the Front Royal Police Department’s investigative division immediately began scrambling for clues, working to learn who would be angry enough to leave behind the scene that responding officers found in EDA Executive Director Jennifer McDonald’s office suite.

There were photographs of McDonald with the face scratched out on the board meeting room table, another photo of McDonald’s face with a knife stuck through the forehead in the seat she normally occupied during board meetings, as well as some defaced family photos, also on the meeting room table. One photo even had a racial epithet scrawled across the face of one of McDonald’s relatives.

According to the Front Royal Police Department investigative file, obtained through a Royal Examiner Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request, McDonald also told police that May 18th morning, that a week earlier, on May 11, 2017, she arrived at work to find a knife lying in her desk chair. There was no signed of forced entry, nor was a call made to police.

Police said there was also no sign of forced or unauthorized entry a week later on May 18, nothing was initially reported missing, and the case remains unsolved.

McDonald told investigators that she wanted to keep news about the incident “quiet”. The FRPD did not issue a press release regarding the alleged break-in and began working the case.

Around 10:30 a.m. the morning of Friday, June 16, 2017, Royal Examiner Reporter Roger Bianchini was asked to come to the Criminal Investigation Division (CID) of the Front Royal Police Department, to discuss his knowledge of the alleged break-in at the EDA and McDonald, someone he had long covered as a local reporter.

As the interview opens, Bianchini explains how through online research Royal Examiner Editor Norma Jean Shaw and he first began to suspect that Truc “Curt” Tran was tied to the proposed regional justice academy and was likely the benefactor who had offered up a no-strings-attached $6 million gift to build the facility in Warren County.

Over the course of the interview, he would clue Investigators Landin Waller and Crystal Cline into the fact that McDonald had informed him, sometimes through texts, of a series of alleged trespass events at her home, including a stone-throwing vandalism through a front door glass window reported to him during a closed-door discussion the previous afternoon in her EDA office between 3 p.m. and 4 p.m., Thursday, June 15.

In Part 2 of this interview, investigators invite Bianchini back around 3 p.m. that afternoon to confirm information he provided in the first interview after a stunning call from the Warren County Sheriff’s Office. That call notified FRPD investigators that the sheriff’s office had responded to the vandalism described by Bianchini shortly after 9 p.m. the previous evening when it was reported by McDonald as occurring some five hours after the reporter said he was told about it.

Through a series of events that would take over a year to unravel, the EDA executive director would come under increasing scrutiny by multiple levels of law enforcement, as well as by the Town of Front Royal, and eventually the County and her own EDA Board of Directors, culminating with her December 20, 2018 resignation, as well as apparent written acceptance of responsibility for the return of $2.7 million in misdirected EDA assets.

Next in the series:

Investigators invite Bianchini back in to confirm information he provided in the first interview after a stunning call from the Warren County Sheriff’s Department.

Share the News:
Continue Reading

EDA in Focus

EDA moves to improve financial accountability, communications & legality



The new-look EDA includes from left, Dan Whitten’s tie, Greg Harold, Tom Patteson, Doug Parsons, Gray Blanton, Bruce Drummond, Ed Daley, Jeff Browne and Gretchen Henderson’s hand. Royal Examiner Photos/Roger Bianchini. Video by Mark Williams.

On the job for under two months himself, Executive Director Doug Parsons greeted Greg Harold and Jeff Browne to their first meeting as members of the Front Royal-Warren County Economic Development Authority Board of Directors shortly after 8 a.m., Friday morning, June 28.

And it didn’t take long for the new members to get their feet wet as the newly-tooled EDA – Executive Director Parsons (on the job since May 8; his Administrative Assistant Gretchen Henderson (May 6); Harold and Browne (appointments announced June 18) – attempts to right itself in the wake of a $21 million financial scandal that has seen criminal charges brought against both former Executive Director Jennifer McDonald and her Administrative Assistant Missy Henry, both of whom remain jailed without bond.

In fact legal consultation regarding the EDA’s nine-defendant civil litigation and Front Royal’s recently-filed lawsuit seeking recovery of an estimated $3 million in Town assets from the EDA, as well as ongoing accounting, loan and debt service issues were two of four topics of a closed session that lasted just short of four hours.

And while there were no announcements about EDA litigation following the closed session’s re-adjournment to open session at 12:42 p.m. there were a series of Resolutions and motions approved designed to increase financial accountability and oversight and to begin marketing some EDA properties seen as financial Albatrosses. Those properties include the vacant warehouse at 426 Baugh Drive, a property at 404 Fairgrounds Road and the former Stokes Mart property now housing the Main Street Market at 506 East Main Street and a currently damaged and un-occupiable three-unit residential apartment building.

In fact the legal tightrope the EDA is walking regarding State Codes that prohibit EDA’s from running businesses or acting as residential landlords was a topic of discussion during the initial open session that began at 8 a.m. Following Parsons’ Executive Report reference to the EDA’s payment of temporary motel housing for the three displaced tenants of the residential apartments in the wake of a tenant vehicle accident resulting in a crash into the building, board member Ed Daley noted the State Code prohibition on certain activities that would place EDA’s in direct competition with the private sector.

Daley worried that the EDA’s initial funding of those three tenants temporary housing gave the appearance the EDA was the residential landlord of the Main Street Market apartment building. However EDA Attorney Dan Whitten explained that the Main Street Market owners, Jeff and Ginny Lesser, were actually the residential building landlords. The EDA leases the entire property to the Lessers with an option to buy, and the Lessers’ lease includes their control of the residential building at the corner of the property. However it was also noted that the Lessers pay the EDA that collected rent, further muddying an already murky business arrangement.

Parsons also said the insurance company of the tenant whose brakes failed causing the crash into the building had agreed to reimburse the EDA for the temporary housing costs at the nearby Quality Inn. Those costs are $1100 dollars per month.

Doug Parsons, left, addresses questions during his executive director’s report Friday morning, June 28.

Responding to a board question, Parsons said that while he did not have a signed agreement to that effect, he did have an email from Progressive expressing its intention to cover those temporary housing costs. It was suggested a signed agreement might firm up that commitment legally.

Also during the afternoon portion of the open meeting the EDA board minus absent Mark Baker, by a 6-0 vote approved Daley’s motion to schedule a special EDA board meeting to prepare for a joint meeting with the Warren County Board of Supervisors and Front Royal Town Council. A date for the three-way joint meeting has yet to be set.

See the above-cited discussions and your new-look EDA at work on a variety of fronts in the linked Royal Examiner video:

Share the News:
Continue Reading

EDA in Focus

McDonald draft statement goes public – another side of the EDA story



Jennifer McDonald planned to make one more public appearance to tell her side of the story to municipal government – her May 24 arrest derailed that plan. But now we have a public release of what she planned to say. Royal Examiner File Photos/Roger Bianchini

A draft of comments former EDA Executive Director Jennifer McDonald planned to deliver at a municipal meeting, likely the Warren County Board of Supervisors, outlines her side of the story regarding multiple allegations at the base of the EDA civil litigation filed March 26. McDonald is the pivotal figure in the nine-defendant lawsuit seeking recovery of what has climbed to over $21 million dollars in allegedly misdirected EDA assets.

McDonald’s May 24 arrest by Virginia State Police on four felony financial fraud and embezzlement charges aborted that planned public defense in front of one of the boards now being criticized for a lack of oversight of EDA operations and McDonald’s role in those operations.

The McDonald draft statement was published June 20th on Kristie Atwood’s “One Mad Mother” Facebook page. For some time Atwood has been publishing materials on her Facebook page that would seem most likely to have been leaked to her from McDonald. Atwood would appear to have a common cause with McDonald – to make the Warren County Administration and Board of Supervisors look bad – if for differing reasons: Atwood has threatened a multi-million dollar lawsuit against the County over building permitting issues with her home, while McDonald asserts many of her actions now cited as fraudulent in nature were, in fact, approved and/or known to EDA and County officials and allowed to proceed.

Kristie Atwood has been a vocal critic of county government in the wake of county permitting of unsatisfactory work on the home she was having built. On June 20 she published the draft of McDonald’s planned statement to public officials telling her side of the EDA story.

McDonald’s draft comments were also hand delivered to this reporter “off the record” by McDonald during a meeting at Samuels Public Library the month prior to her arrest. However, with Atwood’s social media publication of the identical draft statement, though my copy had a sexually-tinged paragraph posted by Atwood crossed out for deletion, Royal Examiner sees an “on the record” opportunity to explore portions the former EDA executive director’s explanation of some of her actions cited as fraudulent by her former employer based on the Cherry Bekaert “working papers” report on indicators of fraud in EDA finances and related real estate transactions.

This initial look will summarize an overview of the five-page statement and then focus on its ITFederal references.

The Blame Game

The gist of McDonald’s draft statement echoes with some specificity her civil attorney Lee Berlik’s written response to the Complaint against his client in the EDA civil litigation:

“The Warren EDA … is engaged in an attempt to smear Ms. McDonald by blaming her for every bad decision made by the Warren EDA board over the last several years and turning business deals the Warren EDA now regrets into implausible conspiracies,” Berlik wrote.

While McDonald does not directly address the $52,000 or more in credit card payments made under the auspices of Afton Inn contractual work that appears to have initially landed her in jail, she does comment on social media references to related allegations in the EDA civil litigation.

“Now I get to read the Facebook comments about how my house, credit cards, and essentially all my bills are paid off and that is simply not true. I still have a mortgage that I have held since 2004 when I built my house, I have a mortgage on rental properties, I have credit card bills, I have all of the bills a normal person has and then some,” McDonald wrote, adding of the social media frenzy she was initially exposed to in the wake of the EDA civil litigation filing of March 26, “This is all based on one-sided opinions, not facts. I continue to be harassed by the Internet crowd, threatened by folks in local stores, and stalked by the crazies and for what?”

From the perspective of an EDA board that continued to support her through November 2018, the “what” is an orchestrated, years-long conspiracy going on under their noses involving multiple projects they, at least in some cases like ITFederal and Workforce Housing, as a board approved the expenditure of EDA resources on.

Why were these people laughing? On April 27, 2017, then-EDA Board Chairman Greg Drescher and Jennifer McDonald find mirth in a motion approving a $445,000 purchase of the 3.5 acre Workforce Housing parcel that was supposed to be a $10 gift. The EDA civil suit cites the property as a $650,000 loss achieved with the Nov. 28, 2018 EDA sale of the property to believed Aikens Group affiliate Cornerstone LLC for $10 – ironically the price the EDA was initially supposed to pay for the property as a ‘gift’ from McDonald relatives in September 2014.

McDonald calls some of these allegations against her, including but not limited to the ITFederal project and other Truc “Curt” Tran-related land moves and the Workforce Housing fiasco and its ever-fluid developmental and cost scenarios, a result of “selective amnesia” on the part of EDA board members and county officials. As noted above, from her perspective that amnesia revolves around the fact that many projects cited as evidence against her, were approved by the EDA Board of Directors with the support of the Warren County Board of Supervisors and/or Front Royal Town Council.

In its civil filing the EDA counters that many of its worst decisions were based on misinformation presented to it by McDonald. But no one from McDonald to her EDA Board of Directors to County or Town officials who gave the okay to various aspects of these projects, explains why virtually no one involved at the EDA or municipal levels did due diligence to get at the truth of what was being presented to them about various projects they were being asked to support with hundreds of thousands and even millions of dollars in investments – whoever it was that was doing that presenting.

McDonald civil cases attorney Lee Berlik wrote on the first page of a defense motions filing of April 16, emphasis in context, “Plaintiff suggests every statement by every counterparty it now regrets crediting was a false statement by Ms. McDonald … instead of a false statement to Ms. McDonald.”

Enter the Dragon

In the ITFederal case the lack of due diligence appears to be at least in part the source of origin bringing the company forward – Sixth District Congressman Robert Goodlatte – that absolved ALL involved, from McDonald to her EDA board, to the town council and county board of supervisors save one former councilwoman, from any semblance of due diligence before handing, not only the Royal Phoenix Business Park (the remaining 117 acres were used as collateral on the $10 million dollar EDA/ITFed loan from First Bank & Trust), but also the “farm” over to Tran essentially for one dollar, American, AND the Goodlatte-suggested $10 million dollars for ITFederal operational expenses.

This way to prosperity then-Congressman Robert Goodlatte promised of ITFederal landing at the Avtex Brownfield site as early as September 2014, when the 147-acre Royal Phoenix site was released for development by the Environmental Protection Agency.

“At the ceremony for the release of the Avtex site (September 2014), Goodlatte (then-U.S. Congressman, R-6th) mentioned to several of my Board members what a great opportunity ITFederal would be for the Avtex site,” McDonald wrote in her draft statement, adding, “We started work immediately to make sure we were doing everything in our power to get this business to Front Royal that we thought would create 600 jobs and a $40 million investment in this community. Everyone was ecstatic that we had finally landed what we thought to be the best project that had come our way in over 20 years,” McDonald writes in her draft statement.

And it was not McDonald, but rather the EDA Board of Directors that authorized a 30-year payback term for Tran to the EDA when the Town “Bridge Loan” was extended to Tran from September to November 2015; while the EDA has a seven-year balloon payback in full arrangement with First Bank & Trust achieved in December 2015. The latter is an arrangement, which as we have reported previously, EDA/County Attorney Dan Whitten explains the EDA hopes to refinance at the seven-year mark allowing it to have Tran continue to cover its bank payments over the life of its 30-year ITFederal loan – a loan McDonald attorneys have pointed out Tran remains current on and within reduced benchmarks approved by the EDA Board of Directors.

What McDonald continues to describe in her defense is a virtually blank check given the ITFederal CEO for every idea that might pop into his, or someone’s, head – like the above-referenced “farm”.

“In fact, the Board not only agreed to give Mr. Tran the land (reporter’s note: 30 acres publicly valued by the EDA at $2 million dollars) for $1 if he met certain milestones, but they agreed to help in the purchase of a farm for Mr. Tran, extend a $10 million loan to Mr. Tran, an incentive package to Mr. Tran, and breaks on utility tie ins. All of this in an effort to make sure the community kept the 600 jobs and the $40 million investment as promised,” McDonald wrote.

An aerial view of the believed ‘Front Royal Farms’ property below the treeline in middle of photo that was purchased by ‘Curt’ Tran, just west of the FRLP property. The Tran ‘farms’ parcel comprises about 80-plus acres in the lower, central portion of photo stretching from Happy Creek Road and the RR tracks to the left. Royal Examiner File Photo/Roger Bianchini Courtesy of CassAviation

Now this is my favorite part of McDonald’s statement – her description of how certain reduced benchmarks on the ITFederal $10-million loan were agreed upon – kill the messenger, aka blame the media (they might be telling the truth):

“When Mr. Tran was being bashed in the local news he came to Mr. Drescher (EDA vice chair) and Mrs. Wines (EDA chair) with a letter in hand stating he was ready to move on to a different community because of the bashing UNLESS (EMPHASIS in context) the EDA considered reducing the scope of his obligation. Mr. Drescher and Mrs. Wines took his letter and concerns to the Board and they ALL agreed to reduce the scope of his project,” McDonald writes (why wasn’t I playing poker with these people back then?!?)

The result of that EDA board-approved reduced project obligation is the thus far empty one-story, 10,000 square foot building standing in lieu of the promised three-building 50,000-plus s.f. complex promised to be the foundation of a $40 million dollar investment resulting in 600-plus high-paying tech industry jobs first promised in a press release from Congressman Goodlatte’s office; not to mention ITFederal principal Truc “Curt” Tran sitting on the bulk of a $10 million dollar loan he has about 27 years left to pay off, with only the apparent necessity he spend about $2 million of it here, and provide 10 jobs of indeterminate wage in the 10,000 s.f. building within the next year.

As late as Dec. 20, 2018, even McDonald critic Tom Sayre, 3 months into civil defamation litigation with the EDA executive director, was proud to pose with ‘Curt’ Tran on site behind EDA headquarters.

In her statement McDonald aggressively counters the EDA civil litigation inclusion of that $10 million at the financial center of fraud allegations revolving around her.

“Now here we stand several years later and the Board has changed, the project has not been completed, and everyone wants to point the fingers at yours truly. I have kept my mouth shut for many years now with all of the bashing, hatred, and down-right bullying that I have endured because of the decisions made, not by me, but by the EDA Board, Town Council and Board of Supervisors. My role as Director was to take the beating for everyone and the decisions that had been made and I did just that UNTIL the accusations of embezzlement, malfeasance, moral turpitude, etc started to role.”

Of the inclusion of that $10 million EDA loan to Tran being part of an alleged, far-reaching conspiracy to enrich herself and her family, McDonald writes, “Not a penny of that money came to me or anyone in my family. 100% of the money went to ITFederal at the closing. All documents were signed by Patty Wines (not Jennifer McDonald). The mere fact that anyone sitting on the EDA Board, Town Council, or Board of Supervisors would even suggest otherwise is pathetic and absurd.”

But again, what McDonald fails to explain, as has everyone else she lists as involved on the EDA, County and Town side (other than Bébhinn Egger), is whether ITFederal and its CEO were EVER in a position to achieve what was being promised, initially by the aforementioned and since-retired Sixth District Congressman Robert Goodlatte. For a small amount of online research, as done by this reporter and Norma Jean Shaw in 2016 would reveal a company, not with a $140-million dollar Defense Department contract ballyhooed by Goodlatte and McDonald, but rather a company struggling for at least five years to realize $35,000 to $50,000 in private sector contracts, among other issues.

Above, an early architectural drawing of the first planned ITFederal building at the Royal Phoenix site totaling about 27,000 s.f. – the reality, below, is a one-story, 10,000 s.f. building with phase one of a nice ‘Western Bypass’ connector road built by the Town headed its way.

Cherry Bekaert details what Royal Examiner’s news staff discovered in 2016**:

“Our research of ITFederal and other associated entities from the Business Plan (ITFederal’s for Royal Phoenix site) indicates the companies are very small (likely less than 10 employees). They maintained unsophisticated websites with little to no physical office locations and TRAN’s home residence appears to be the main headquarters of ITFederal and VDN (a second Tran company, VDN Systems). ITFederal, VDN and ACRC (a third Tran company, American Commonwealth Regional Center) appear to be shell companies with little to no invested capital and questionable customer base representations e.g. spouses and/or near relatives (“Katrina Tran” and “Tran CPA”) holding executive positions,” page 40 of the Cherry Bekaert summary states.

In fact, the EDA fraud investigator reports that “startup capital” for ACRC’s Virginia Information Technology Project, LLC – apparently the ITFederal Royal Phoenix project – was listed as $2,022,000, $2 million of which was the publicly-stated value of the 30 acres gifted to ITFederal behind closed doors by the EDA for one dollar.

“Hence, the startup capital represented by TRAN in the Business Plan appears to be little more than $2,000 cash and $20,000 in other current assets, both of which were unverified,” Cherry Bekaert reports.

And of that much-ballyhooed $140 million federal contract with the Nuclear Regulatory Commission that was to be the basis for ITFederal’s $40 million dollar, 600 high-paying tech jobs investment in this community, Cherry Bekaert observes, “… our research indicates ITFederal LLC and VDN Systems, Inc, both controlled by TRAN, were listed … with one award from the Nuclear Regulatory Commission for approximately $5,000 in 2014, not the $140,000,000 represented in the Business Plan.”

SURE, let’s give him ALL the money he wants, or doesn’t want – Congressman Bob-a-lot and Jennifer said it’s a GOOD idea!

So while there may be plenty of blame to go around; and McDonald may have developed her own “selective amnesia” as to what unauthorized or self-serving financial or real estate moves ostensibly on behalf of the EDA she may have made, it is McDonald who until June 24 sat alone in jail without bond. And now that there has been a second arrest, it is one downward on the EDA/Municipal hierarchy, rather than up as McDonald seems to assert she believes the case should be.

“Based on suspicion and belief” from public comments at County and Town meetings in the wake of the March 26 filing of the EDA civil litigation, it is an opinion a significant number of people in this community share.

** FOOTNOTE: Evidence within the EDA financial investigative report notes that Goodlatte’s office called McDonald in an effort to silence the 2016 media “bashing” of ITFederal. It reports a consequent call from McDonald to WZRV owner Andrew Shearer about the matter, which perhaps coincidentally, almost immediately was followed by the termination of Norma Jean Shaw as station news director – Shaw was on the Goodlatte side of the WZRV news team exploration of ITFederal – and a terse email from Shearer shutting down this then-WZRV new team member’s inquiry to ITFederal officials about the company’s contract base. So the year after his sudden lockout from the paper he helped create, Bianchini was released from the WZRV news team about a month or so after Shaw.

The then out-of-work investigative news team was soon reunited at the newly created Royal Examiner online newspaper. As this reporter wrote in one of his first stories for Royal Examiner (October 27, 2016) revealing the one dollar giveaway of the 30-acre ITFederal parcel: “One of the best-kept secrets in Front Royal and Warren County seems to be the cause of a year-long delay in federal approval of the FIRST commercial property sale at the remediated Avtex Superfund site in Front Royal. In fact, we had to start a new online news source just to get that reason published and into the public conversation – just kidding, sort of …

Share the News:
Continue Reading


Decision on former EDA Administrative Assistant bond deferred to mid-July



In a devastating decision for at least 12 family members and friends present for her first court appearance since being arrested the previous day on two felony charges related to the EDA financial scandal, a decision on bond for former EDA Administrative Assistant Michelle “Missy” Henry was deferred by retired substitute Judge Thomas Horne on Tuesday morning (June 25).
Consequently Henry could remain jailed until mid-July though Horne left open the option of expediting a bond hearing if Judge Clifford L. Athey Jr., who has thus far handled the other civil and criminal cases related to the EDA investigation, sees fit to.

A hearing date of July 19 was set to revisit Henry’s bond, with an option for a July 11 date possible. Circuit Court Deputy Clerk Janice Shanks told the court that Athey would “be in the building” on July 11, but that circuit court was not scheduled that day. However, it appears Athey could convene court July 11 if he thought Henry deserved an earlier consideration of her bond request.

It appears Missy Henry will remain in jailhouse garb until the judge thus far handling EDA matters, Clifford Athey Jr., returns to the circuit court bench for one of the final times in July. Photos/RSW Jail website

Athey is in the midst of preparing for a move to the Virginia Appeals Court in September as Warren County prepares for a judicial juggling act. That juggling includes current Circuit Court Clerk Daryl Funk’s move to the bench in Juvenile and Domestic Relations Court and current J & D Court Judge William Sharpe’s move to the Circuit Court bench. However, it was noted during Tuesday’s hearing discussion that Sharpe would likely recuse himself from EDA cases because he knows involved people.

And speaking of involved people, Assistant Commonwealth’s Attorney Bryan Layton argued that like her former EDA boss Jennifer McDonald, Henry should be denied bond. Athey twice denied bond to McDonald, citing her as a possible flight risk were she to have access to even 10% of the allegedly misdirected EDA assets now cited at over $21 million.

Layton informed Judge Horne of the scope of the EDA civil litigation seeking recovery of those millions of dollars. He noted that among the 12 felony indictments McDonald has thus far been served, wire transfers were involved which he noted “Henry normally assisted in” though he did observe that Henry has not been charged related to those McDonald wire transfer-related indictments.

As indictments mount up for her role in the sometimes mysterious workings of the EDA over the past five years or so, Jennifer McDonald has seen a second related arrest, but not of anyone with decision-making or oversight authority over the EDA’s executive director. Courtesy RSW Jail

What she is charged with Layton told the court, is involvement in the handling of one property the EDA purchased and made a small business loan to in order to help finance a retail operation in. It is involvement Layton concluded was “a betrayal of the public trust” in prefacing his request that Henry continue to be held without bond on the two felony financial charges against her.

UPDATE: Second former EDA staffer arrested on embezzlement charges

“The prosecution is trying to shoehorn her on to collateral charges against the other, main defendant,” attorney Ryan Nuzzo said in rebutting Layton’s portrayal of his client.
Nuzzo noted that the dates of the charges related to the B&G Goods transactions at the base of his client’s case were between October 1 and December 30, 2016 and September 1, 2014 to December 30, 2016.

“These are very old actions …If she was a flight risk she would have fled by now,” Nuzzo told the court.

Nuzzo pointed out that one family member not present for Henry’s Tuesday morning hearing was her husband Garnett. That absence was due to medical issues with his back in the wake of a backhoe accident from which he has recurring symptoms. His client, Nuzzo told the court, was instrumental in helping her husband through the “bad spells” he encounters as a consequence of that accident. Much of that assistance comes in the home Missy and Garnett Henry built and have lived in since 1990, Nuzzo pointed out of his client’s long-time ties to this community.

Her attorney also argued that being free on bond would allow Henry to better assist in preparation of her defense against the charges. Nuzzo told the court Henry has no previous criminal record and had been cooperative whenever she had been called before the Special Grand Jury looking into the EDA matter.

Ironically it is the same Special Grand Jury that handed down the two sealed, felony indictments against her.

RSW Jail Superintendent Russ Gilkison said that following her bond hearing Tuesday, Henry was transferred to the Prince William Adult Detention Center. The move, similar to McDonald’s June 11 transfer to the Fairfax County Adult Detention Center, is called a courtesy hold and does not cost the transferring facility any additional housing costs above what would be incurred if the inmate remained housed where they were booked.

As with McDonald the move is to allow a more normalized experience of incarceration for Henry. Due to the emotionally volatile and high-profile nature of the EDA case involving the alleged misuse of public funds for personal gain, McDonald had been held in protective custody isolation from the time of her May 24 arrest until her June 11 transfer from RSW. Responding to a question, Gilkison said the fact Henry and McDonald are co-defendants in that same high-profile case factored into the decision not to transfer them into the same facility.

Share the News:
Continue Reading

Local Offers

King Cartoons

Front Royal
06:0020:37 EDT
Feels like: 100°F
Wind: 3mph S
Humidity: 54%
Pressure: 30.04"Hg
UV index: 9

Upcoming Events

1:30 pm Botanical Drawing 1 @ Art in the Valley
Botanical Drawing 1 @ Art in the Valley
Jul 16 @ 1:30 pm – 4:00 pm
Botanical Drawing 1 @ Art in the Valley
Learn and practice the art of botanical drawing in pencil with local artist and instructor Elena Maza. Tuesdays: 1:30pm – 4:00pm, July 9th – 30th. Classes will be held in our upstairs studio at 205[...]
6:30 pm Pour Me Another Fluid Art @ Strokes of Creativity
Pour Me Another Fluid Art @ Strokes of Creativity
Jul 18 @ 6:30 pm – 8:30 pm
Pour Me Another Fluid Art @ Strokes of Creativity
Two classes in July – the 18th and 26th at 6:30pm. Pre-Registration is a must! Pour Me Another is an actual class. You will learn the ins and outs of paint pouring and go home[...]
5:30 pm PAVAN Showcase Performances @ Sherando High School
PAVAN Showcase Performances @ Sherando High School
Jul 19 @ 5:30 pm – 9:00 pm
PAVAN Showcase Performances @ Sherando High School
You are cordially invited to PAVAN Showcase Performances: 5:30 pm – Solo Recitals 5:30 pm – Art Gallery Open House: Browse art works at your leisure 7:00 pm – Concert performances by Guitar, Theatre, and[...]
10:00 am Design a chair for the SPCA CHAI... @ SPCA of Winchester, Frederick, and Clarke Counties
Design a chair for the SPCA CHAI... @ SPCA of Winchester, Frederick, and Clarke Counties
Jul 22 @ 10:00 am – 5:00 pm
Design a chair for the SPCA CHAIR-ity Brunch @ SPCA of Winchester, Frederick, and Clarke Counties
Calling all artists!! Design a chair for the SPCA CHAIR-ity Brunch and save homeless animals. Pick up a chair from the SPCA Thrift Shop, build a chair, up-cycle a chair, paint a chair, or upholster[...]
1:30 pm Botanical Drawing 1 @ Art in the Valley
Botanical Drawing 1 @ Art in the Valley
Jul 23 @ 1:30 pm – 4:00 pm
Botanical Drawing 1 @ Art in the Valley
Learn and practice the art of botanical drawing in pencil with local artist and instructor Elena Maza. Tuesdays: 1:30pm – 4:00pm, July 9th – 30th. Classes will be held in our upstairs studio at 205[...]
6:30 pm Pour Me Another Fluid Art @ Strokes of Creativity
Pour Me Another Fluid Art @ Strokes of Creativity
Jul 26 @ 6:30 pm – 8:30 pm
Pour Me Another Fluid Art @ Strokes of Creativity
Two classes in July – the 18th and 26th at 6:30pm. Pre-Registration is a must! Pour Me Another is an actual class. You will learn the ins and outs of paint pouring and go home[...]
3:00 pm Teacher Classroom Door Hanger @ Strokes of Creativity
Teacher Classroom Door Hanger @ Strokes of Creativity
Jul 27 @ 3:00 pm – 6:00 pm
Teacher Classroom Door Hanger @ Strokes of Creativity
Welcome in the new school year with a Personalized Classroom Door Hanger! Make your choice of a pencil, bus, apple or cloud sign. Must preregister with deposit of $10 and the choice of shape by[...]
12:00 pm Crop With Us @ Strokes of Creativity
Crop With Us @ Strokes of Creativity
Jul 28 @ 12:00 pm – 5:00 pm
Crop With Us @ Strokes of Creativity
Come Crop With Us Sunday, July 28, 12 noon to 5:00 pm. Receive a gift for pre-registering and attending. $15 No refunds. Feel free to bring your own snacks or drinks!
10:00 am Design a chair for the SPCA CHAI... @ SPCA of Winchester, Frederick, and Clarke Counties
Design a chair for the SPCA CHAI... @ SPCA of Winchester, Frederick, and Clarke Counties
Jul 29 @ 10:00 am – 5:00 pm
Design a chair for the SPCA CHAIR-ity Brunch @ SPCA of Winchester, Frederick, and Clarke Counties
Calling all artists!! Design a chair for the SPCA CHAIR-ity Brunch and save homeless animals. Pick up a chair from the SPCA Thrift Shop, build a chair, up-cycle a chair, paint a chair, or upholster[...]
10:00 am Let’s Explore Art @ Strokes of Creativity
Let’s Explore Art @ Strokes of Creativity
Jul 29 @ 10:00 am – 12:30 pm
Let's Explore Art @ Strokes of Creativity
Monday July 29th – Wednesday July 31st – Friday August 2nd 10:00 AM -12:30 PM Ages: 6-9 $100 per student: Includes an art supply kit and snack & drink Day One: Lines, lines, they go[...]

Advertise your business to 30,000 local readers for FREE


Advertise your business to 30,000 local readers for FREE

Our new LiveMarket Local Offers lets you promote your business to locals 24/7. Click below to get your 1st promotion going… no credit card required, no strings attached.

Create Your Promotion