Connect with us

EDA in Focus

Judge takes dueling evidentiary objections ‘under advisement’ in EDA vs. ‘Curt’ Tran/ITFederal civil case and counterclaim

Published

on

Attorneys for plaintiff “Warren Economic Development Authority” (EDA, WC EDA, FR-WC EDA) and civil case defendant Truc “Curt” Tran/ITFederal argued motions filed in objection to some evidence each party plans to introduce at trial over the last seven work days of this month. Jury selection is slated for Thursday, July 21, with the trial beginning the following day, Friday, July 22, with the entire following week July 25-29 set aside for completion of presentation of evidence and arguments in that approximately $9-million EDA civil case claim and defense counterclaim.

As appears to be common in such civil liability cases each side attempts to set an evidentiary framework that best suits their claim of either liability or lack thereof. Judge Bruce D. Albertson took both motions related to relevance to the EDA’s claim for a return of the unpaid balances on two EDA loans to Tran and his company originally totaling $12 million, and a counter-claim by Tran of EDA liability in his being misled by the former EDA executive director, under advisement.

Judge Albertson noted he has previously expressed some “skepticism” about the defense objection to EDA evidence about Tran and his company’s use of portions of the $12 million it received in two loans related to proposed development here, primarily at the Avtex/Royal Phoenix Business Park site in Front Royal, for other business ventures in Alexandria or elsewhere. However, the judge said he would reserve a final decision on admissibility until he sees how the flow of evidence is presented at trial. As noted above, the claim is for approximately $9 million, as Tran has kept current on his $40,000-plus a month loan payments.

The EDA contends Tran acquired the EDA loans fraudulently and conspired with then-EDA Executive Director Jennifer McDonald in doing so. Disputed evidence cited also related to EDA involvement in development of a Criminal Justice Academy and Tran’s Front Royal Farms plan, neither of which came to fruition along with the failed Avtex site business proposal.

Tran’s counterclaim appears to revolve around the contention he was taken advantage of by McDonald, and that the EDA Board of Directors at the time should have identified the alleged financial improprieties McDonald is now accused of by the EDA prior to Tran’s involvement. Pointing to a primary disputed aspect of the EDA-Tran/ITFed counterclaims of liability, Judge Albertson observed, “If he’s part of a conspiracy with McDonald, he’s not a victim of the negligent contention.”

The EDA vs. Tran/ITFederal civil trial is slated to be the final of five scheduled for this month, beginning with the just-concluded April Petty case. As previously reported, on Thursday, July 7, a jury found Petty liable for the return of $125,000 in EDA funds used by former EDA Executive Director McDonald to pay off the balance of an Ocwen Mortgage company loan to Petty during the March 2016 sales process on Petty’s Howellsville Road home. McDonald was acting as Petty’s real estate agent through Campbell Realty at the time she was also EDA executive director. See: Civil Case Jury finds April Petty liable for return of $125,000 to EDA

Jury selection is scheduled for this Monday, July 11, in the EDA vs. Donald Poe/Earthright Energy case, with the remainder of the week to Friday, July 15, booked for trial on that civil liability claim of over a million dollars. That case revolves around a contract McDonald was alleged to have been involved in to have the company provide solar panels to the Warren County Public Schools facilities as it did to the EDA office complex; however, allegedly without proper authorization.

Also on the civil court agenda for this month are the EDA vs. Samuel North (one day, July 18); and William Lambert (two days, July 19/20).

Front Royal, VA
63°
Rain Shower
7:03 am4:54 pm EST
Feels like: 63°F
Wind: 0mph N
Humidity: 65%
Pressure: 30.04"Hg
UV index: 2
MonTueWed
64°F / 34°F
50°F / 27°F
50°F / 41°F
Start Your Day With A Smile5 hours ago

Jest A Moment: What if America Had Taken the Turkey Under Its Wing for a National Symbol?

Interesting Things to Know6 hours ago

Overtime Tax Break Gets Easier to Claim in 2026, but Not All Extra Pay Qualifies

Food6 hours ago

The Surprising History Behind Two Thanksgiving Dishes We Think Have Always Been There

Local News24 hours ago

Small Hands, Big Hearts: Young Bell Ringers Bring Christmas Cheer to Front Royal

Historically Speaking1 day ago

Israel: The Fourth Aliyah

Jefferson Forum1 day ago

Taxing Talent and Farmland is Bad Policy for Virginia

Local News1 day ago

Wings of Excellence Academy Turns Holiday Food Drive into Year-Round Mission

Obituaries1 day ago

Maria Lane Himes Miller (1942 – 2026)

Commentary & Analysis1 day ago

JFK & The Woman Who Knew Too Much

Interesting Things to Know1 day ago

Can a Dog Really Have Its Own Smartphone? Meet the PetPhone

Interesting Things to Know1 day ago

How Thanksgiving Leftovers Helped Pave the Way for LASIK Eye Surgery

Obituaries1 day ago

Joyce Bailey Evans (1940 – 2026)

Local Government1 day ago

Cannabis Ordinance Goes Forward with Recommendation of Approval from Town Planning Commission

Local News1 day ago

VDOT: Warren County Traffic Alert for Nov. 23 – Dec. 4, 2026

EDA in Focus1 day ago

Avtex Trail Advisory Subcommittee Emerges at FR-WC EDA Meeting

State News2 days ago

Spanberger Expands Housing Plan Into Three-Year Strategy, Calls for Scrutiny of Corporate Landlords

Local News2 days ago

Front Royal Seeks Applicants for Economic Development Authority Board Vacancy

Local Government2 days ago

Notes from the Front Row: Inside the First Night of Front Royal’s Citizens Academy

State News2 days ago

Virginia Consumers to Receive $4.2 Million in Relief as Attorney General Targets Robocalls and Fraud

Local News2 days ago

Virginia State Police Report Nearly $454,000 in Drug Seizures During Weeklong Operations

Business Growth Series2 days ago

Business Growth Series: Burned-Out Businesses Don’t Grow

Agriculture2 days ago

Virginia Awards $722,000 to Help Farmers Fight Crop Diseases, Improve Food Safety, and Increase Production

Local News2 days ago

Virginia Home Sales Drop Nearly 14% as More Houses Sit on the Market

Community Events2 days ago

From a Front Yard in Maryland to a Bus in Front Royal, Communities Come Together to Fight Hunger

Commentary & Analysis2 days ago

Commentary: Will Virginia Join Other States in Banning a Pesticide Linked to Parkinson’s disease?